Judges are not independent in Armenia, says Ombudsman

19:22 • 22.04.11

Armenia’s Human Rights Defender referred to the right to fair trial as he criticized the situation in judicial system and said that judges in Armenia are not independent.

In statement published on the website of Armenia’s Human Rights Office, Karen Andreasyan said that around 40 per cents of appeals to the Ombudsman in 2010 were related to the right to fair trial.

“The courts are supposed to defend people’s rights against state agencies, private companies and other people, while very often people need to be protected against the courts,” Andreasyan wrote in the statement.

“My authority enshrined by the law is to protect people against all the state bodies except the courts.

“Due to the unfairness of separate judges, the apparent omissions by the top leadership of judicial power and under the imperfect conditions in the judicial system people are losing their sense of justice and as a result they become extremely disappointed with all the state institutes,” Andreasyan explained.

Further, he said that thanks to various experts and international organizations it was fixed in Armenia’s Constitution that the judicial system must enjoy absolute independence.

However, he said that judges in Armenia are not independent as the control over the judges is being implemented either by the upper courts or by the Justice Council that mainly consists of judges.

“I strongly believe that today a judge is not independent as an individual as he/she can be subjected to pressure by the leadership of the top judicial power,” wrote the Ombudsman.

“Today that leadership is neither accountable nor responsible in front of the public because there are no legal mechanisms for a legitimate control of the judicial body,” he added.

According to him, the only mechanism to curb the injustice in the inter-state judicial system is the European Court of Human Rights that saw an increasing number of lawsuits filed against the Armenian state recently.