Court ruling against Yerkir daily was disproportionate – NGO

19:27 • 27.06.11

The Council of Media Disputes has said that the court ruling against Yerkir daily to pay MP Tigran Arzakantsyan 200,000 drams (approx $530) for the word “urchin” was disproportionate.

In a statement released on Monday it said that the court could rule that the newspaper apology and publish a denial.

The Council further said that the article for which the daily was brought to court was written in a humorous style but was based on real facts.

It also said that the word “urchin” used in the article in reference to Tigran Arzakantsyan is offensive.

However, it said that the work was used in quotation marks, which means it was a direct quote of the words of another person.

The Council also said that the reporter, however, did not identify the source at the court which means the quote had been made “dishonestly”.

It also said that the amount of the sum demanded in compensation (3 million drams – approx $ 8000) for insult and libel runs counter to the principles of relevance of intervention and necessity.