New conflict, if arisen, may spread beyond Armenia and Azerbaijan
Peace talks over Karabakh may not only encourage – they may fatigue as well, an ICG expert has said.
Speaking to Capital Daily, Project director for Caucasus of International Crisis Group, Lawrence Sheets, in retrospect to the trilateral meeting in Kazan, observed such intonations in the messages of the heads of OSCE co-chair states...
"Do you think that the meeting in Kazan has failed the expectations of experts and general society?"
"I would say it has failed expectations rather than hopes. There were hopes on the two sides which were not fulfilled. Expectations is a different term: they reflect something which was expected to happen. So evaluating these as hopes which were not fulfilled would be more realistic."
"Turkey's Prime Minister Erdogan has recently declared inability of OSCE Minsk Group to resolve the Karabakh conflict in almost 20 years. Do you believe Turkey is interested in assuming mediator's mission?"
"I thnk the notion of negotiations between Turkey and Armenia, whether they be officual negotiations or talks at the diplomatic level, seem to be continuing, at least at some level. As for Turkey becoming a party to the Madrid talks or negotiations between Azerbaijan and Armenia, I don't think that's something realistic at this stage. The reasons are obvious: I don't think that Armenia would regard Turkey as a natural party to the negotiatons' format. So despite these informal contacts betwen Turkey and Armenia, I don't believe that Turkey would become a formal negotiator in the talks between Azerbaijan and Armenia over Karabakh."
"Kazan meeting has been the 9th presidential summit of Sargsyan, Aliyev and Medvedev in the last 3 years. What may be the reasons for the activity of Moscow in the negotiation process?"
"Russia has been very active, but things have not turned out as we hoped so far. I would expect that Russia would continue to take a very actuive role in peace talks. Russia believes it is in its own political interests – particularly people like president Medvedev. They understand that's not in the interests of Russia to have a new and a hot war at full scale between Azerbaijan and Armenia, which would lead to a full scale Russian involvement. This may depend on how long the patience by both sides will hold out. I would say Russia is holding a much more active role than ever before. There are of course political actors in Russia who are perhaps pursuing their own agendas, but I think without any doubt Russia has done the forefront of at least trying to sit the two presidents down at the table and initiating talks."
"What could be the benefits for Russia in case of becoming the main contributor to the conflict settlement?"
"Russia would like to maintain good relations with both Azerbaijan and Armenia, altough Azebaijan is not a formal Russian ally. Armenia, on the other hand, is a formal ally through the CSTO mechanism, which means that Russia and Armenia have formal military obligations, at least on paper. In any case, I think there’s an understanding that a new war is not in Russia's interest – the interest, in the long run, is to have stability in the South Caucasus without any wars."
"Do you think that Russia is supposed to engage in the Nagorno Karabakh conflict if it goes hot, without being bound by any obligations?"
"What sort of obligations Russia has, depends on how you read the various protocols, statements, and agreements between Russia and Armenia. Formally, as far as we undersand, any military action involving Armenia, which would mean action on Amenian soil, would trigger the CSTO mechanism, under which Russia will be obliged to provde military support. But there are various interpretations by both sides whether or not his may cover Nagorno Karabakh in practice."
"Do you think that the leakage of content of the roadmap of steps to coflict settlement on the eve of Kazan meeting could imply a message to both sides to advance in negotiations?"
"I think that leakage has been an instrument of diplomatic pressure, which could have been used by different sides. It's very difficult to judge, because there's no official information, only sources from various governments in the region, including Russia and Azerbaijan, and de-facto Nagorno Karabakh. It's very difficult to say what is actually the case, was there any sort of agreement ever agreed upon, or there are various rumors which came out in the fom of leaks."
"How do you interpret the messages of the presidents of MG OSCE countries, particularly the phone calls of Barack Obama to Sargsyan and Aliyev?"
"Obama, Sarkozy, and Medvedev have made equal statements. I think they express the degree of fatigue in the negotations process, pointing to the fact that this is going on for 19 years without any real tangible results. There are many other conflicts in the world, and I think there's a concern in Washington, Europe, and Moscow about the possiblity of a new conflict and what it might mean, because it is unlikely it will be limited only to Armenia and Azerbaijan, but could spread to Turkey and Russia. I think, this is what the presidents were trying to convey."
"What future negotiation scenarios do you observe?"
"We don't believe that the Minsk process is completely over We hope that perhaps, sometimes, negotiations are taking place away from official formats, even without the presidents sitting down for talks, and I hope the two sides will see the wisdom of compromise in the coming weeks or months. And we hope there will be further meetings between high-level Armenian and Azerbaijani officials, includng the two presidents. And then we hope there will be a compromise or agreement. If that does not happen, we are going to see increasing tension, with belligerent statements and war threats: basically the so-called frozen situation benefits no one."
Thank you
By Aram Gareginyan









