Territorial integrity principle for Azerbaijan?

19:14 • 11.08.11

In an interview with Analitika.at.ua,Vahram Atanesyan, Chairman of the Standing Committee on Foreign Relations, Parliament of the Nagorno-Karabakh Republic (NKR), commented on the Armenian public figure Georgy Vanyan's statement that "Armenia must recognize Azerbaijan's territorial integrity. It is not until Armenia does so that all the other issues can be discussed."

He said: "It is comforting to know that Armenian and Azerbaijani experts are 'testing the ground' to lay the foundations for 'good neighborly relations'. I also mean some articles – seen as 'extraordinary' ones in Azerbaijan - by Zardusht Alizade. What Alizade and Vanyan have in common is their phobia about 'the Empire' e.i. 'the Russia Empire.' The point is, however, that both of them, unwittingly, propose serving another 'empire' – the one of 'universal democracy' – which, similarly to the 'Russian Empire,' disregards international legal principles, and human morals as such, when their vital interests are jeopardized.

"By and large, there is no difference between NATO's calls for 'respecting Kosovars' rights' and 'peace enforcement operation in Georgia to save the Ossetian people from genocide.' Of course, there was a real threat of genocide both in Serbia and in Georgia. However, it is also true that, in splitting Serbia and Georgia - first actually and later legally – the NATO members and Russia were acting in their own national interests. And if anyone hails Kosovo's independence, this one should also hail that of Abkhazia and South Ossetia. This one must also struggle for the independence of Nagorno-Karabakh, Transnistria and so on.

"Turkey, although recognized Kosovo's independence, has not so far recognized Abkhazia despite forming some economic ties with that territory. Similarly, Azerbaijan does not officially recognize the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus, whereas hundreds – if not thousands – of Azeri students are studying at the higher schools of that unrecognized country. The sides were even rumored to be establishing direct air communication. May be airplanes flying from Baku to Turkey then fly to Northern Cyprus.

"It is illogical when European diplomats say Kosovo cannot be a precedent. Why can't it? There is not a reasonable answer to this question. I recall the OSCE Minsk Group French chairman's words that, unlike Kosovo, there is no 'international presence' in Nagorno-Karabakh. As if Serbs 'petitioned' for 'international presence' in their country. It is common knowledge that this 'international presence' is – excuse my pun - 'present' in Kosovo. Nor did Georgians ask Russia to 'force them into peace' and construct its military bases in South Ossetia and Abkhazia.

"No country would ask for foreign presence except for urgent cases. Any presence against the country's will is nothing but occupation. Turkish presence in Northern Cyprus is occupation of part of internationally recognized Republic of Cyprus. Is Turkey ready to recognize an EU member's territorial integrity? Is Ankara ready to withdraw its troops from Northern Cyprus? No. So what's Turkey's right to demand 'the de-occupation of Azerbaijani regions along with Nagorno-Karabakh'? In words Azerbaijan condemns any occupation. However, I cannot recall Baku condemning the occupation of part of Cyprus, Serbia or Georgia. At a news conference held jointly with the Turkish prime minister, Azerbaijani President [Ilham Aliev], in answering a Turkish journalist's question concerning the recognition of the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus, dropped a clear hint that 'there is a time for everything'. That is, 'we will recognize it after we settle the Nagorno-Karabakh problem.'"

Referring to the Declaration on Principles of International Law, Atanesyan said it contains the best definition of the principle of territorial integrity. According to it, the territorial integrity of an independent state can be respected only if the state respects the principle of peoples' equal rights and self-determination.

"Did independent Azerbaijan respect the principle of peoples' equal rights and self-determination? No, it did not. Suffice it to say that the legal act abrogating the autonomous status of Nagorno-Karabakh of November 24, 1991, was one of the first legal acts declaring Azerbaijan's independence.

"Considering the above, we can ask: can the principle of territorial integrity apply to Azerbaijan? I address this question to Mr. Vanyan, an apologist for Azeri propaganda. Let's wait for his answer."