Ombudsman asks justice minister to combat injustice in the judiciary
Armenia's human rights defender, Karen Andreasyan, has called upon the justice minister to take active measures to combat injustice in the judiciary.
In a letter addressed to Hrayr Tovmasyan, the ombudsman asks for launching a disciplinary proceeding against three judges who were earlier reported to have issued unfair rulings.
It comes after three citizens lodged claims with the Ombudsman's Office, complaining that judges had been unfair in relation to them. Having reviewed scores of similar appeals, the Ombudsman selected those three, considering the judges involved in the proceedings in gross and blatant violation of the law.
"The ombudsman had submitted to the Justice Ministry's Disciplinary Board reports on each of the three judges and informed the society about that. But he immediately came under public attack after statements containing disinformation, deluding quotations from legal acts, unlawful calls and illiterate accusations were made on behalf of different judiciary organs," reads a statement by the Ombudsman's Office.
It says that the Ministry of Justice rejected all the three reports, considering that there were not sufficient grounds for filing a proceeding.
Arguing the decision, the Ombudsman's Office says that evidence of a blatant and gross violation of one single legal norm is enough for filing a disciplinary proceeding , while the committee's response saying "there were not sufficient grounds" implies that there was at least one ground in each case. In the meantime, it says the Judicial Code of Armenia does not clearly specify how many grounds are necessary for launching a proceeding.
In response to the Ombudsman's notice on the above mentioned, the committee said it had given an exhaustive answer.
Not considering the process exhausted, the Ombudsman has now submitted his claim to the Justice Ministry, another body responsible for filing proceeding against judges.
It particularly calls for taking appropriate measures to restore the claimants' trust in the judiciary, protect the society from unlawfulness by holding judges accountable, and reduce monopolistic and clannish approaches in the system, relieving law-abiding judges of unnecessary disciplinary pressures.









