Freedom House Nations in Transit 2012 report registers progress in Armenia

12:10 • 06.06.12

Freedom House has released Nations in Transit 2012 report which is the annual analysis of democratic development in Central and Eastern Europe and Eurasia.

 

At a time of growing economic uncertainty, the report warns of rising antidemocratic tendencies in Hungary and Ukraine that have the potential to take root elsewhere in the region.

 

The report says negative developments in Hungary and Ukraine are at the forefront of an antidemocratic trend in Central and Eastern Europe that raises serious questions about the durability of the European Union’s young democracies, as well as prospects for aspiring members. The report notes Hungary’s year-on-year performance as the most glaring example of democratic decline among the newer European Union (EU) members, where the combination of weak traditions of democratic practice, resilient networks of corruption and clientelism, low levels of public trust, and shaky economic conditions have hampered the achievement of indelible democratic reforms.

 

Five other EU member states in the region—Bulgaria, the Czech Republic, Lithuania, Romania, and Slovakia—have also experienced net declines over the past five years. Ukraine, which saw a brief democratic opening after the Orange Revolution in 2004, has suffered significant decline in an alarmingly short period of time. Under the Yanukovych government, Ukraine’s Nations in Transit ratings worsened in five categories year on year, with a steep decline in judicial framework and independence and an overall democracy score that is rapidly approaching its pre–Orange Revolution level. Ukraine’s downward trajectory, like the negative trend among a number of EU hopefuls in the Balkans, raises real doubts about the prospects for widening the circle of democratic states in Europe.

 

The failure of virtually any of the countries of Eurasia to shed old governance habits and end monopolies on political and economic power has been one of the greatest disappointments of the past two decades. The overall democracy scores of most Eurasian countries either declined or remained unchanged. Fearing the demonstration effect of the uprisings in the Arab Middle East, authoritarian regimes in Belarus, Azerbaijan, and Kazakhstan cracked down hard on protesters in 2011, using the full weight of their pliant judiciaries to preempt and punish dissent.

 


Declines were most numerous in the judicial framework and independence category in 2011, appearing in every subregion covered by Nations in Transit. A total of eight countries—Albania, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Bulgaria, Hungary, Kazakhstan, Russia, and Ukraine—regressed on this indicator.

 


The report says the year was not without successes for the former Soviet region. In Moldova, the media environment continued to benefit from an increased diversity of outlets and a more professional public broadcaster. And the introduction of e-government services in Georgia and Armenia was seen as a positive step in the effort to address low-level corruption.