By the time of Serzh Sargsyan’s election much of Armenia was already sold - Chatham House

14:54 • 21.06.12

Home of the Royal Institute of International Affairs, Chatham House has published its 2012 report - The Long Goodbye: Waning Russian Influence in the South Caucasus and Central Asia.

 

In his report, the author, James Nixey, states that Russian influence in the independent states of the South Caucasus and Central Asia is weakening; the drift is inexorable but Russia employs multiple instruments to counter this. “In the South Caucasus, Armenia has already succumbed to Russia economically, with ramifications for its sovereignty. But Azerbaijan and Georgia, via different paths, have moved away from Russia’s embrace,” the report states.

 

“The levers of Russian influence here vary. They are economic and military in Armenia, scarcely present in Azerbaijan, and essentially related to negative publicity as well as economics with regard to Georgia. Russian influence in Armenia is so great that lack of sovereignty should be Armenia’s number one concern,” the author says.

 

According to the report, Russian influence in South Ossetia and Abkhazia has increased. The costs and problems associated with these dependencies suggest to some that Abkhazia and South Ossetia are millstones around Russia’s neck. However, the Rs7.7 billion ($250 million) Russia spends on them each year is a trivial sum.

 

Referring to Nagorno Karabakh, the report says Russia’s support of Armenia in the Nagorno-Karabakh dispute has been based on several interests: limiting Turkish influence, countering a Russophobic Azerbaijan in the early years of independence, and long-standing cultural ties reflected in the large Armenian diaspora in Russia. “Russia’s positioning has given it a powerful lever of influence over Armenia and Azerbaijan, as well as external parties. However, its backing of Armenia’s stance has changed in recent years: during his presidency, Medvedev invested more effort in mediation than his predecessors and the Azerbaijani first family has strong interests in Russia,” the report continues.

 

The author writes that a full-blown renewal of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict would jeopardize Russia’s position in Azerbaijan and Turkey, particularly if the Armenians required military assistance. Pipeline security would also be affected, and Russia prioritizes energy security and financial profit over conflict manipulation.

 

“In 2003, the CEO of United Energy Systems (UES), Anatoliy Chubais, outlined plans to integrate the South Caucasus into a Russia-led energy-supply network through ten former Soviet republics, as well as plans to ensure electricity outflows from Armenia to Turkey and Azerbaijan. Chubais denied that UES sought political gains but he has been a leading proponent of the concept of a Eurasian ‘liberal empire’ and his actions gave Russia almost total control of Armenia’s energy market. It was Robert Kocharian, Armenia’s president from 1998 to 2008, who effectively sold off Armenia to Chubais and other Russian commercial and political interests.

 

Through Gazprom’s ownership of its Armenian subsidiary, ArmRosGazprom, 80% of Armenia’s energy structure is Russian-controlled, including the majority of the Iran–Armenia gas pipeline, thus ensuring that Armenia cannot become an independent transit country should Iranian gas ever reach European markets. Russia has also bought up all but two of Armenia’s hydroelectric and nuclear power stations, in exchange for writing off Armenian debt. The extent to which Russia has acquired concrete political gains from energy and infrastructure ownership is a source of debate within Armenia. Kocharian’s successor, Serzh Sargsyan, is ostensibly less pro-Russian but by the time of his election in 2008 much of his country had already been sold,” the report states.

 

According to it, in the non-energy commercial sectors, the Russian airline Sibir owns 70% of the Armenian airline Armavia. The state-controlled Russian bank Vneshtorgbank owns 70% of the Armenian Saving Bank. “Russia has effectively bought up Armenia’s national railway network with a $570 million investment. Russia’s greatest economic lever with Azerbaijan and Armenia is in the form of migrant workers and their remittances,” the report states.