ICG: 2013 presidential election opportunity to prove statesmanship in Armenia

10:36 • 26.06.12

The 2013 presidential election in Armenia will determine whether the country has put in place a government with the legitimacy needed to implement comprehensive reform and resolve its problems with Azerbaijan, the International Crisis Group (ICG) has said in a report.


“President Serzh Sargsyan has a brief opportunity to demonstrate statesmanship before he again faces the voters in what is likely to be a competitive contest. Sargsyan has demonstrated some courage to promote change, but like his pre-decessors, he has thus far failed to deal effectively with serious economic and governance problems, including the debilitating, albeit low-intensity, Nagorno-Karabakh war. Another election perceived as seriously flawed would serve as a further distraction from peace talks and severe economic problems. The likely consequences would then be ever more citizens opting out of democratic politics, including by emigration.


The genuinely competitive parliamentary election had some positive signs. Media coverage during much of the campaign was more balanced, and free assembly, expression and movement were largely respected. The president’s ruling Republican Party won a solid majority of seats, but its former coalition partner, Prosperous Armenia – associated with rich businessman and ex-president Robert Kocharyan – came in a strong second. The Armenian National Congress (ANC), led by the first post-independence president, Levon Ter-Petrossian, returned to parliament after a more than ten-year absence. Nevertheless, many old problems reappeared: abuse of administrative resources; inflated voters lists; vote-buying; lack of sufficient redress for election violations; and reports of multiple voting and pressure on some voters. Reforms adopted after the violence that left ten dead and 450 injured following the 2008 election that brought Sargsyan to power were spottily implemented,” reads the document.


The authors of the report emphasize the importance of holding the cleanest elections in Armenian history” while President Sargsyan is seeking a second term. The further refer to president’s bold steps over the recent years, particularly his efforts to normalize relations with Turkey. The ICG experts note that younger generation of politicians - under-40 technocrats – has emerged in this period favoring a new style of government. But the consider the progress very slow and call for political courage to overhaul what they call a deeply entrenched system “in which big business and politics are intertwined in a manner that is often at least opaque.”


“The political crisis after the 2008 post-election violence, as well as the 2009 world economic crisis, shook Armenia. Weak political will and the resistance of vested interests muted many of the long-overdue, if timid, reforms the administration started. The economy consequently remains undiversified, unhealthily reliant on remittances. Rates of emigration and seasonal migration abroad are alarmingly high. There have been few serious efforts to combat high-level corruption. The executive branch still enjoys overwhelming, virtually unchecked powers. The judicial system is perceived as neither independent nor competent: the prosecutor dominates procedures, and mechanisms to hold authorities accountable are largely ineffective.
Media freedom is inadequate. Outright harassment of journalists and media outlets has decreased, but there is still a glaring lack of diversity in television, from which an overwhelming majority of Armenians get their information. No nationwide broadcasters are regarded as fully independent.”


Noting that Russia remains Armenia’s key ally, the authors of the report note that the country has few realistic alternatives to Moscow because of the war with Azerbaijan and frozen ties with Turkey. According to them, the EU and US should increase their influence not only in terms of expertise and other aid to promote reforms but also, and more importantly, in terms of keeping the government accountable and encouraging the building of democratic institutions.


“President Sargsyan and his government acknowledge many of the most pressing problems, but numerous reforms exist only on paper or seem deliberately designed with ineffective enforcement mechanisms. The cautious, evolutionary approach to reforms provides at best weak stability. The breakup of the Republican-Prosperous Armenia governing coalition and a more competitive parliament may now provide the stimulus the administration needs. Limping towards change, however, would neither capitalise on Armenia’s strengths nor be a good presidential campaign strategy. The country needs a better future than a stunted economy and dead-end conflicts with neighbours,” says the report.