For a fistful of dollars - Hungarian expert
By Péter Farkas Zárug
Professor, political analyst
I was reminded of Sergio Leone’s epic western, when I heard that the Azerbaijani soldier who with premeditated and vile purpose axed to death the sleeping, innocent Armenian serviceman, Gurgen Markaryan, was extradited to Azerbaijan – with total disregard of any diplomatic considerations by the second Orbán cabinet – in expectation of “a fistful of dollars”. Greedy Joe, wanting to serve this side and that, but with his own gain – i.e. the financing of the Hungarian state debt – foremost above all moral principles, has now fallen into a trap. In Hungary the foreign policy of the second Orbán cabinet has arrived at its final bankruptcy.
At the same time the world must know that in this question the Hungarian, Christian people stand not by the government, but by the gravestone and the family of the murdered Christian Armenian soldier, Gurgen Makaryan. The Hungarian nation does not want blood money for the Armenian serviceman, it abhors the promise of a fistful of dollars.
The falsehood of the deception
Because indeed, since 2010 the delegation of the Hungarian Government has even twice rolled the dice over the shroud of the Armenian Christian martyr, and in its pharisean way allowed the rich and powerful to win, so that they - accepting the swindle as a friendly gesture – will some place, some time let the betrayer win, let him grab a fistful of dollars.
There is no one today in the civilised Christian world, who receives not with acute embarrassment or loud denunciation the act of the muddle-headed, blundering Hungarian Foreign Office in returning Major Ramil Safarov to his home in Azerbaijan.
The Foreign Affairs’ vacuous excuses and the sheepish presentation on behalf of the Orbán cabinet of a memorandum to the Azerbaijani ambassador in Budapest, all aim to prove that from János Martonyi to Zsolt Németh, from Péter Szíjjártó to Viktor Orbán everyone was convinced that the Azeris will keep Safarov in prison until the end of his life.
They are trying to make us, Hungarians, the Christian nations of the world and the Armenians of the world believe that they trusted the Azeri promise that the ax murderer will be treated as guilty and subject to due punishment. In their pronouncements they all prevaricate, like Judas to Caiaphas, claiming that along with a handful of silver pieces Caiaphas also promised not to harm Jesus. However, to refer to dumb-witted ignorance and credulity and to the fact that it was not a fistful of dollars but international extradition treaties that governed the case, is simply lying. As in fact, following the 2004 language training course within the NATO Partnership for Peace, during one night of which an Azeri officer hostile to Armenia executed in his sleep the Armenian serviceman, official participant at the event, it became clear that:
1. Hungary had no extradition agreement with Azerbaijan
2. For a crime committed on its territory, Safarov was to face trial for murder in Hungary
3. Safarov could not be repatriated for trial, since due to the state of war with Armenia, his act would not be regarded as a crime by Azerbaijan
4. Bearing in mind the above, according to the code of practice and rules of international law, the sentence also needed to be enforced and served on the territory where the crime was committed, i.e in Hungary
5. The international judicial interdiction of extraditing Safarov thus did not only apply to to the trial stage of the case, but also to the duration of serving the sentence.
The Armenian Embassy in Vienna brought all this in great detail to the attention of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, which under the then leadership og the Hungarian Socialist Party was largely responsible for grave organisational errors in failing to prevent this murder. Leaders of FIDESZ, then in opposition, were fully informed about the case, the Parliamentary Foreign Affairs Committee keep ing them thoroughly briefed on all details. The socialist foreign-officers were inevitably forced by the christian half of the world to account for their incredible negligence that led to the murder by an Azeri Muslim of a Christian Armenian. Attila Mesterházy, the current socialist president would be better advised to offer his apologies to the Armenian people and the family of Gurgen Markaryan, rather than rushing for political gains to the forefront of demonstrations. Leave that to us, who also raised our voice in 2004 against their incompetence.
So the judicial principles, which are now so misleadingly being proffered to the Hugarian public stating that the Hungarian officialdom simply followed a tested extradition scenario, but ‘lo and behold’ was double-crossed by these crafty Azeris, were already very well known by all concerned in 2004.
After having allowed an Armenian soldier to die in his sleep, the least the socialist organisers could do was to to have applied all circumspection in investigating the crime and enforcing due punishment. Until the Azeri opening by Viktor Orbán.
Orbán’s Eastern opening
In the spirit of eastern opening and in pursuit of sources for the external financing of Hungarian state debt, in his second premiership Viktor Orbán has already paid two visits to Azerbaijan.
He has been in negotiations with President Ilham Aliyev – son of Heydar Aliyev, the communist ex-KGB boss promoted to president – who pardoned Safarov the minute his plane landed in Baku. He rewarded the ax murderer with a new apartment, promotion and back-dated wages, while the Azeri foreign office expressed its gratitude to the Orbán cabinet for more than a year’s fruitful co-operation.
Of course in Hungary each played the same tune, that the silver piece is not his, he struck no deal, nor indeed was there ever a word uttered around the dinner tables laden with Eastern wealth and arrows of irony aimed at EU bureaucrats about a fistful of dollars. Albeit only a week earlier it was the Orbán-leadership itself that boasted in its media that it was on the brink of a three billion [forint?] government bond agreement with Azerbaijan.
However, the Safarov case – today equally acknowledged by the Azeris as well as Prime Minister Orbán – is certain to have appeared on the agenda of the ‘semi-Asian’ brotherhood’s convention in Baku. All those who are today demurely silent on the subject are judases to the memory of the brutally assasinated Armenian soldier.
And today, we Hungarians, Christians and Europeans ask the question: how did the avowed national, Christian and democratic second Orbán cabinet get mixed up in such a betrayal of civilisation?
Who is the one and who are those who reckoned that the disregard of the internationally legitimate right to justice of a victim will in the long-term yield the reward of the Armenian’s blood, the fistful of dollars? One wonders whether the governemnt correctly assesses that this is in the longer-term interest of Hungary, for which it is worth swallowing this ‘tiny’ bitter pill.
How long can one impute interests to again and again trample underfoot our moral fundaments, only because there are some who – following today’s increasingly confused Hungarian foreign policy directions – assert that: this is the Hungarian interest!
No! The interest of the Hungarian people – with or without the expected Azeri billions – would have been that the Hungarian state defend its sovereignty and Safarov complete his prison sentence in Hungary.
It was not a Hungarian interest to be branded as Judas by the entire Christian civilisation. It was not in our interest to be made the laughing stock of the international community of nations.
No! All well-intentioned Hungarians, Armenians, Christians, Europeans and democrats are united in their protest against this. This is alien to our civilisation.
We are Chrsitian brothers
As the Armenian people must well know, the Hungarian people are not their enemy, but their friends, their Christian brothers. Do not burn her flag, because Hungary has for centuries been the host, the home-giver and the provider of protecting shelter to the Armenians. Hungary has at all times empathised with the Armenian suffering, which the Armenian people have borne and continue to bear to this day on their body and soul. The two people have always lived in peaceful and serene symbiosis which should not be tarnished by the misguided, iniquitous decisions of a few.
This is why every Christian Hungarian and Hungarian-Armenian intellectual must raise his voice and loudly proclaim: the Hungarian nation is not party to this betrayal of civilisation!
Has the professed Christian and national Orbán government considered this?
Have they taken into view that from Paris to Brussels, from Rome to Beirut, from California to Washington, from Sidney to Darwin, from Moscow to Minsk every – often affluent and influential – Armenian, who throughout the world, as in Hungary too, adhere in their majority to Christian national ideals, only associate with Hungary and with the name of Viktor Orbán a single thought: the betrayal of justice and Christianity? It would appear, not.
What hurts most is that neither the decision-makers of the present atlantist-zionist-disposed Ministry of Foreign Affairs, nor the neophytes of Eastern orientation among Orbán’s closest collaborators in foreign relations appear to be particularly shaken by the case. They merely continue the pursuit of their personal prestige, and without any apology “regard the matter closed”! Except that, morally adrift, they have no idea of the scale of the damage they have caused, the real risk of their decision.
What are today’s instructions, guidelines for ambassadors of Hungary? How are they expected to respond wherever in the world they are asked the question: are you not familiar with those articles of international law which in extradition cases of criminal offenders demand careful consideration of the eventuality that the recipient country may for political or military reasons exonerate the subject of any punishment? It they are truly ignorant of the law, does that not point to their barabarism? Yet if they are indeed aware of all legal requirements and implications, then what interests drive them to betray justice? Perchance, a fistful of dollars?
So what should Hungarian diplomats stand for?
They can see with crystal clarity that an inept, venal government was beguiled amidst bountiful feasts by a wealthy and artful eastern power to become a traitor, the betrayer of justice and of its own culture. And now, those who played with the honour of the Hungarian people plead that Caiaphas promised them something else.
No matter: in this affair they seek their fistful of dollars, we, Christian Hungarian democrats stand by the cross on the grave of Gurgen Markaryan.









