ECHR returns verdict against Armenia in Virabyan v. Armenia case

22:35 • 04.10.12

In today’s Chamber judgment in the case of Virabyan v. Armenia (application no. 40094/05), the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) ruled that Armenia is to pay €31,000 to Grisha Virabytan as compensation, with moral damages reaching €25,000.

The ECHR held that there were two violations of Article 3 (prohibition of torture and lack of an effective investigation) of the European Convention on Human Rights concerning Mr Virabyan’s torture in police custody and the authorities’ failure to investigate the related allegation, the lawyer Tigran Ter-Yesayan told Tert.am.

The ECHR also ruled that there was:

a violation of Article 6 § 2 (presumption of innocence) of the Convention as concerned the reasons for terminating the criminal proceedings against Mr Virabyan;

no violation of Article 14 (prohibition of discrimination) in conjunction with Article 3 as concerned the allegation that the torture had been politically motivated;

and, a violation of Article 14 in conjunction with Article 3 as concerned the authorities’ failure to investigate whether the torture had been politically motivated.

In April 2004, Grisha Virabyan, a member of the opposition People’s Party of Armenia, was detained and brought to the Artashat police station, where he was mercilessly beaten for several hours until he lost consciousness. He received serious traumas and underwent surgery. Thereafter, police initiated criminal proceedings against Mr Virabyan.

The policemen that used violence against his were not punished, Ter-Yesayan said.

He noted that the ECHR set an unprecedented amount of compensation, €6,000 plus €25,000 as moral damages.

“The problem is that our government informed the European Court of its insolvency. But the European Court is well aware of such arguments and considers them untenable,” the lawyer said.

In similar cases involving EU member-states the ECHR rules compensations up to €100,000.

As to the reasons for the ECHR raising the compensation rates, Ter-Yesayan said that “the ECHR is thus seeking to put an end to the stream of complaints from Armenia and warn the country that it high time for it to pay attention to such facts.”

“He was imprisoned for eight years and finally won the case. But what about the consequences? The persons responsible for violence are still holding their posts, the government does not punish them in any way,” the lawyer said.