No judges held liable as a result of Eueopan Court rulings vs. Armenia
No judges in Armenia have been held accountable as a result of the European Court of Human Rights rulings against the country, according to a Judicial Department official.
Speaking to Tert.am, the head of the Department’s International Cooperation and Public Relations Service, Arsen Babayan, said those rulings stemmed from conflicting provisions in the domestic legislation and the European Convention of Human Rights, with the Strasburg Court strictly guiding itself by the letter of law when issuing a judicial act.
The local daily Haykakan Zhamanak said earlier this month that the Court’s rulings vs. Armenia have caused the Government to pay an equivalent of €1,225 from the State Budget since 2007.
“In addition, there are over 1,000 complaints in the European court, but only 47 have been satisfied. If we compare the ECtHR ruling vs Germany, in this respect, they outnumber those against Armenia in percentage terms,” Babayan said.
Speaking of the conflicting provisions that cause the court to rule against Armenia, Babayan pointed out to the Zhirayr Sefilyan case.
Sefilyan, who was a special detachment commander in Shoushi during the Nagorno-Karabakh liberation war, was detained in December 2006 over charges of making public calls for changing the constitutional order through violence. He remained in prison until June 2008.
The European Court ruled that the procedures of eavesdropping on Sefilyan’s phone conversations and keeping the activist in prison for around eight months were implemented in violation of the Convention which guarantees everyone’s right to security and liberty of person (Article 5), and respect for private and family life (Article 8).
Commenting on the ruling, Babayan said it resulted from discrepancies between the Convention and the Armenian legislation.
Precedential rulings are now being used as a guideline to smooth over the existing problems.
“And by the way, the ECtHR clearly refers to the Cassation Court ruling in its decision,” Babayan noted.
Asked whether the domestic courts’ rulings might be motivated by a political instruction, Babayan characterized such allegations as baseless political statements. According to him, the rulings versus Armenia do not mean anything, with the Court satisfying only a third of the proceedings filed.









