Cabinet proposes restrictions on prisoners’ correspondence confidentiality

12:49 • 27.12.12

The Armenian cabinet has proposed amendments to the Penitentiary Code to restrict the convicts' right to confidential correspondence. 


The new chapter, proposed to the law on restricting the correspondence of inmates (both those sentenced for life and those serving a certain period of time), first describes the procedures for submitting and discussing a motion for imposing such a restriction. The bill requires that the document justify the reasons behind the proposed measure, including the necessity to observe law and order in the penitentiary institution, ensure the protection of public health and moral standards, and the constitutional right of inmates.


The motion has to specify the timeframes and grounds of restricting the confidentiality of correspondence and be submitted with supporting materials.


Its appropriateness is to be considered by court. The motion is also subject to appeal.


Based on a court ruling, the head of the penitentiary institution is then required to make a decision on opening a letter written by or sent to the convict.


Under the proposed bill, the letters addressed to the minister of justice, the European Court of Human Rights, the prosecutor general, the ombudsman, an ordained clergyman-confessor, groups of public observers conducting a monitoring in prisons and penitentiary administrations and defense lawyers or medical institutions are not subject to opening or confiscation.


A justification attached to the legislative proposal says that the Penitentiary Code envisages no measures for the prison administration to examine and confiscate an inmate’s letter without violation of the relevant provisions of Armenia’s Constitution and the European Convention on Human Rights.


“This legislative gap leads to a lots of difficulties related to the protection of justice, and observance of security and order in prisons, the protection of public health and moral standards, and others constitutional rights,” reads the document.