Armenia’s Constitution still topic of debate despite 18 years’ history

13:40 • 05.07.13

Photo by Aravot.am


The president of Armenia’s Constitutional Court sees no serious imperfections in the country’s basic law despite the existing controversies over major flaws.


In comments to Tert.am, Gagik Harutyunyan said that the Constitution has been reformed to a sufficient degree in the past 18 years (since its adoption) to have the possible risks reduced to a minimum level.


“Three out of the six ways to constitutional reforms are doomed to passiveness in our country,” he said, noting that Armenia preferred the path of constitutional law by adopting its basic law in 1995. “Armenia chose the adoption of the constitutional law, regulating the relations in the initial years. What our life demanded then was constitutional solutions because moving forward otherwise was impossible.”


Harutyunyan noted that Armenia simultaneously opted for adopting a model constitution which implied a certain degree of localization. “That became quite widespread in the countries which sought ways out independently after collapses,” he said.


Speaking about the risks of constitutions, Harutyunyan explained that such risks are real to an extent that they allow for transforming regulations from one model into another. “That’s like transplanting an organ, which often makes a second phase necessary. So the question is what to do to reduce those risks to a minimum,” he added.


As for the gaps, the Constitutional Court’s president noted that serious measures have been taken since 1998 in order to bridge them. “They were somehow finalized in 2001 when the Venice Commission undertook the elaboration of constitutional reforms together with representatives of seven countries. The package contained 25 countries’ constitutional practice, offering possible solutions to the existing problems. That, however, wasn’t adopted at the 2003 referendum.


“Certain solutions were found in 2005 when when the Venice Commission actively promoted amendments,” he said.


But political analyst Andrias Ghukasyan doesn’t share Harutyunyan’s views. He sees more gaps rather than advantages in Armenia’s basic law.


“For the public, that Constitution is a law restricting rights. That’s also an institution of state monopoly, with the ruling party making a decision who to appoint where and to what position. The Constitution does offer that exclusive authority. Those are the shortcomings of the constitution; there’s no separation of power or balance. There’s no constitution here at all,” he told our correspondent.


Citing the Constitution’s key thesis, which says power in the Republic of Armenia belongs to the people (Article), the expert said that the violations begin right from there.


“That’s a core thesis whereas the National Assembly, which is the representative body under the Constitution, is under the criminal-oligarchic system’s control. We saw the representative body seized through fake elections and the distribution of bribes. The people are deprived of the constitutional right to exercise power. Hence our people have to use the direct forms of exercising power; that’s disobedience and civil struggle,” Ghukasyan added.