Implications of Association Agreement deal depend on content, says ex-minister

20:55 • 21.08.13

A former Armenian minister of defense thinks any implications of the Association Agreement (which is to be initialed later this year) depend upon the text on the table.


In an interview with Tert.am, Vagharshak Harutyunyan said negative effects will be inevitable in case the document contains conflicting provisions in terms of the Armenian-Russian cooperation.


Dear Mr Harutyunyan, we already hear the ruling Republic Party of Armenia say that Armenia is ready to initial the EU Association Agreement in case nothing out of the ordinary happens. What do you think will be the implications in terms of military security and economy? I mean the possible steps by Russia.

The implications will depend on the document’s content. If there are clauses conflicting with the Armenian-Russian agreements and creating obstacles to a future cooperation with the Customs Unions or otherwise conflicting with Russia’s interests, the consequences will be definitely negative.


[Director of the CIS Countries Institute] Kostantin Zatulin has said in an interview with Tert.am that he is not aware of the text under negotiation but is quite familiar with the agreement signed with Ukraine.


The negative implications will address all the possible sectors – political, economic and military, and the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict settlement will be naturally an integral part of that. Our diplomatic success today is linked to first of all the military balance which we ensure through the partnership relations with Russia. If not Russia’s support – also in the economic sector (energy, transport, job market, transfers etc.) – our economic situation would me more serious, preventing us to ensure the development of Karabakh. And the paces of migration would be higher, causing serious security concerns also for Armenia.


On the other hand, Armenian politicians say Armenia, together with Karabakh, cannot simultaneously integrate into both systems – the Eurasian Union and the EU. And there is a zero difference in that case, with Karabakh not being involved in the process. Do you think there are differing details in case of the Eurasian [Union] and the EU?


Yes, there are. To understand whether or not there is a difference, we must first of all evaluate the situation today. Who assists in the security of Karabakh and our economic developments? The EU role is little in such efforts, reduced to zero as far as security is concerned. Membership in the Eurasian Union will reinforce Armenia’s economic development, strengthening also Karabakh. As for the initialing of the Association Agreement, it will have no security impact. Economically, it will be zero even in case of the most optimistic assessments.


Russia is known to have sold 1 billion Dollars worth weapons to Azerbaijan. For the pro-Russian circles in Armenia, the fact became an extra argument substantiating the need of the Eurasian integration. Russian experts say in their comments that Azerbaijan had some way or another to buy the weapon from a third country.


Russia has committed itself – under the agreement “On the Russian Military Base” – to supplying Armenia with weapons. After the provision took effect, the arms race between Azerbaijan and Armenia switched over to the Azerbaijani-Russian domain. For Russia, this is a pointless race likely to lead only to an economic collapse. Military operations in the region are strongly against the Russian interest. That’s self-evident. So, with all this in mind, the reasons behind the weapons sale fall into place. Strengthening its influence on Azerbaijan while gaining advantages from the deal, Russia provides Armenia with equipment of a corresponding quantity and type and thus maintains the military balance. The concerns would be well-timed had Russia failed to fulfill its obligations under the agreement.

What can you say about Russian President Vladimir Putin’s visit to Azerbaijan, which was aimed the expansion of bilateral ties and the signing of military cooperation documents?


If you closely look at the documents signed in Baku, you will see there is no serious accord in political-military terms. It is very noteworthy that Putin did not visit their Pantheon. This is an important fact. When Aliyev voiced tough remarks, saying that the territories in Karabakh are “under occupation” and so on, Putin gave a brief response, i.e. – the Karabakh issue will have only a peaceful solution. The statement by the Russian president contains also another message: that Russia does not accept a military solution.

Do you think the initialing [of the Agreement] will cause Russia to decrease its economic investments in Armenia?


If Armenia signs a document conflicting with Russian-Armenian agreements and the Russian interest, undesirable consequences will be inevitable.