Armenia should have ratified ICC Statute to pave way to EU accession - politician
In an interview with Tert.am, a former presidential candidate, Andrias Ghukasyan, commented on Armenia's decision to accede to the Customs Union, the country's failure to initial an Association Agreement with the European Union (EU), as well as on a number of challenges facing Armenia.
Mr Ghukasyan, you have repeatedly raised you voice against an Association Agreement with the EU. You were one of the first people to raise the issue of Nagorno-Karabakh’s future in the context of Armenia’s initialing the Association Agreement with the EU. On September 13, you left a message on your Facebook message to the effect that the joint statement by Armenian President Serzh Sargsyan and Russian President Vladimir Putin on September 3 posed a threat to the interests of the Armenian and Russian peoples. You wrote that “the policy aimed at torpedoing [the Association Agreement] will have adverse consequences for Russia and Armenia in the context of their relations with the European Union.” You are said to have made a U-turn. If it is not so, explain, please.
I said that a number of sensitive issues were immediately related to Armenia’s initialing the Association Agreement with the EU – such issues as the border with Nagorno-Karabakh, status of the Armenian-Iranian border and trade policy. I expressed my concern because the text of the Association Agreement was not available except for a draft text of the Agreement with Ukraine. In this context, raised all the issues. I think they should have been discussed, but labeling – if anyone dared make any critical statement concerning the Association Agreement with the EU, that one was at once branded as “pro-Russian.” All those stating that an Association Agreement with the EU was an issue of serious consequences for geopolitical orientation and that the issue needed transparent and substantial discussions were accused. But the situation is quite different now.
Of course, joining the Eurasian Union entails similar problems, and they have not to date been settled. I also included one more issue in my message. If Armenia did not find it advisable to initial the Association Agreement with the EU, it should have refused to be involved in the process. Because the choice between the Association Agreement with the EU and the Eurasian Union is an artificial choice. Such a choice is not on the political agenda. The constituent documents on the Customs Union have been drafted since 2008, when no Association Agreement with the EU was on the agenda. Naturally, Armenia had nothing in common with that. Armenia has so far not got Armenian translations of the constituent documents on the Eurasian Union. Therefore, it is wrong to claim that Armenia is faced with the ‘either…or’ choice or getting involved in the process of initialing the Association Agreement with the EU, or the Russia-Kazakhstan-Belarus Customs Union. I think Armenia’s leaders were well aware of the impossibility of singing the Association Agreement with the European Union, and there were most serious reasons for that. I think one of them is Armenia’s failure to ratify the Statute of the International Criminal Court in the Hague. I cannot imagine President Serzh Sargsyan and his political team recognizing the jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court over them because of the problems of Nagorno-Karabakh and March 1 case. Summing them up, I rule out such a step on the part of Serzh Sargsyan and his team. Armenia’s authorities have been unable to make this step since 1999. The point is that in 1999 Armenia signed the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, but has not ratified it so far.
So, you think the International Criminal Court can be a supra-state body which can sue the Armenian authorities; therefore …
Yes, there are crimes which are subject to the jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court, and it is competent to hold the country’s leadership criminally accountable for the offenses committed. Supporters of [first President] Levon Ter-Petrosyan applied to the International Criminal Court of Hague in connection with the March 1 [2008 post-electoral turmoil], and we know the ICC prosecutors accepted the complaints filed against [second President] Robert Kocharyan. Because Armenia does not recognize the ICC Statute, the case wasn’t considered, but once it does, the case will be taken under proceeding. And the main reason Armenia did not associate itself with the EU is that we should have recognized the Hague as an international criminal court.
Did the Association Agreement contain the clause on acceding to and recognizing the Hague court [jurisdiction]?
That’s a mandatory clause. If you have a look at the text of the Association Agreement with Ukraine, you will see that Ukraine recognizes the ICC Statute under a separate article. And that’s natural because all the member states of the EU recognize [the ICC legislation]. And association with Europe means accession to all the key legal-political institutions recognized by that Union. It was visible to me that the ruling group would never take such a step.
My opinion was that the regime used the European Union and the European People’s Party for purposes of reproduction, with no one originally wishing any association with Europe. That was an illusive process that made the EPP and the EU its victims. If the EU develops the understanding that Russia lays obstacles to regular developments, this can have such consequences as [the decision] not to take part in the 2014 Sochi Olympics etc. And what happened on September 3 [the day President Serzh Sargsyan made the statement on the CU membership at a meeting with the Russian leader in Moscow] was the worst form of renouncement Armenia could have ever chosen. It not only characterized the Armenian authorities as non-reliable partners but also involved the leadership of the Russian Federation in such a political gambling.
Well, we now seem to have the chances of membership in the CU. At least, assurances are given that the political statements will be followed by legal processes. Are you in favor of the Customs Union?
I find that the state problems which had been earlier raised in Armenia can and are now regulated through a free trade agreement with the Customs Union. There are, of course, problems in terms of the technical regulations, standards of goods and their uniformity, but they are not a reason for joining the CU. Because I have very big doubts that Armenia, with its participation, may affect the standards development process. First, because they are joining the Union too late: that Union and the legislative bases were established in 2008 whereas Armenia is submitting a bid for acceding to it only now. We are now joining a ready organization having legal regulations; hence we cannot change things according to our ideas. It should have been done in 2008 if there was such a political concept. It is obvious today that the economic aspect of these problems can be settled in another way. Therefore I think that membership in the Customs Union will have more negative rather than positive aspects for Armenia. And in general, I am against such decisions without any discussions with the political forces, the society and economists. Their decision does not underpin anybody’s will, except that of the ruling classes. ”
So are you now against the CU accession?
I expressed my political position in my pre-election platform. I support Armenia’s being a ‘neutral’, independent and self-reliant state not represented in any geopolitical union. My position hasn’t changed, so it isn’t now that I am against it.
When you say Armenia shouldn’t have involved Russia in that, do you mean Russia will now have to accept us into the Customs Union?
Those are questions relating to a very close, narrow circle. If, in the coming 4-5 months, Russia demonstrates such a position in its foreign policies that will be perceived by the world community as conflicting, those countries will naturally make a decision not to take part in the event [the Olympic games] because it is only for countries that both struggle for peace across the globe and seek an interstate cooperation. Russia today is gaining a negative image because of such developments, and that’s a blow to the Russian nation’s interests.









