NGO taxation plan is logical, says Armenian blogger
The proposal for imposing taxes and establishing control on non-governmental organizations is absolutely logical, says a blogger
“It is important to have an open access to everything - whether a grant provided to the state or an ordinary organization - in order to know how much people get and what they spend [the resources] on,” Tigran Kocharyan, a blogger better known to the online community with the nickname Pigh (elephant), told Tert.am.
It comes after reports in the press said Prime Minister Tigran Sargsyan has issued an instruction for considering a legal measure on grant taxation.
The move was thought to be the authorities' attempt to follow the example of Russia and Azerbaijan whose governments sought control over foreign grants through taxation and centralized scrutiny mechanisms.
Kocharyan, however, disagreed to those allegations, noting that the United States’ government has the highest level of control over NGOs. He said it is normal for an NGO to make salary deductions for taxes without facing a requirement to pay a profit tax (as NGOs are considered non-profit organization).
The blogger admitted in the meantime that the NGOs’ activities are not very often transparent. “I haven’t yet seen considerable results as far as the ‘grant-eating’ oligarchs are concerned. [I don’t know] who gets how much annually as the [money] comes from here and there, mostly from the American side, but no NGO makes its report public for now,” said the blogger.
Kocharyan noted that the NGOs in the United States are under strict control because of their status as a “foreign agent”.
“If the state has security concerns, it has to establish control over organizations collaborating with foreign countries. I don’t speak about opening or closing [an NGO], but control is necessary,” Kocharyan said, adding that he himself does not very often understand what many NGOs do in practice.
The blogger said most of the NGOs are simply doing a business by lashing out against the government.
“I will bring an example: reports submitted to the US Embassy last year said Armenia faces the same restrictions on freedom of press as does Azerbaijan. Azerbaijan, where journalists are caught, beaten and subjected to violence every year, is not absolutely comparable with Armenia. Simply, if those people write everything is all right, the organizations giving grant will think the topic is closed. People get a salary here and own Geeps, so why should they deprive themselves of all that?”
What’s even more, the blogger said, oligarchs have a predominant interest in specific grant proposals, particularly those concrning the environmental sector and the sexual minorities.
As for the donor organizations, Kocharyan said they pursue two objectives: political and economic. Politically, they seek to exercise pressures upon the country; in economic terms, they are lining their pockets through guest experts, the blogger added.
“They offer a consulting worth, for example, 1,000 Dollars or Euros per day. They provide the consultation for a month, and that’s all. I have worked at an organization of the kind.”
Kocharyan noted that apart from several local NGOs who really pursue honest goals, the rest do not absolutely carry out the work they are intended to.
According to the blogger, several countries, including Turkey, offer grants to Armenia through foundations conducting a campaign against the Armenian Apostolic Church (by establishing organizations declaring themselves as religious minority unions) in an attempt to boost migration from Armenia.









