Bread and circuses – Armenian political engineer on public protests

17:08 • 15.11.13

In an interview with Tert.am, the political engineer Karen Kocharyan shared his views on the social disobedience movements gaining momentum in Armenia. Though the expert hesitated to say whether the protests are from the “bread and circuses” series or part of a program, he noted definitely that the people may eventually focus on survival issues.


Mr Kocharyan, after the Ukrainian media published a report saying that a KGB dossier had been submitted to the president, Ukraine’s signing of the EU Association Agreement came to be thought likely not only to be postponed for a year but also absolutely ruled out. It is notable that the ruling majority feels obviously pleased with the fact.


I have already had the occasion to share my views on that on Facebook, saying that the fact has made many Armenians happy. There is a proverb saying, misery loves company.

This is again from the series of moral victories specific to the Armenians. So, if they have urged us [to choose the Eurasian Customs Union membership], they can do the same with others.

That’s how you comment on it. What I say is, misery loves company. I want to do it in style. More seriously, I think that everything has its price. And the one who pays the price makes the decision. I don’t think Europe is going to pay anything to either Ukraine or Armenia. About 85% of Ukraine’s trade turnover is with Russia, so everything came to a halt there [in Ukraine] after Russia recently closed its border.

So it is the economic factor that works in the case of Ukraine, with Armenia being motivated by security [concerns]?

In the case of Armenia, we deal with not only security, but also the same economic factor because, if you have noticed, the possibility of bringing financial resources from Europe and different organizations was used to be widely discussed, and the visits to Europe were quite frequent. A big delegation went to WB or IMF and returned empty-handed. So it neither promised nor gave any money.


After Russian president Valdimir Putin’s repeatedly postponed visits to Armenia (although the Armenian side states his earlier visits had not been officially announced and so they cannot be considered postponed), the Russian leader will be on a visit to our country. What can be expected?


With respect to the “postponed visits” you have mentioned that no official announcements had been made. I do not know if the upcoming visit has been announced. I think statements on the development of cooperation with the Customs Union should be expected. I also think the issue of balance is expected to be settled. Putin visited Baku so he has to visit Yerevan. He sold Smerch to them, and he is bringing it here to maintain the balance in the security context.


Vice-Chairman of the [ruling] Republican Party of Armenia (RPA) Armen Ashotyan recently spoke of anti-Russian sentiments in Armenia.


I do not know what Mr Ashotyan said. But I think that we have both anti-Russian and anti-West sentiments in Armenia. We also have pro-Russian sections. This is the largest part of Armenia’s population, and their relatives are sending money to their families living here. And, unfortunately, the smallest section is pro-Armenian.


There is an opinion that protests actions are part of the authorities’ programs, including the “bread and circuses” program. Do you share this opinion?


I do not know if they are part of government programs, but I know that a moment comes when no one is any longer interested in circuses because people need bread. If you ask show business personalities, they will complain that they do not give as many concerts as before because very few people attend concerts now. People are more apathetic now and have no time for anything but earning daily bread.