Karabakh will be the price for Armenia-Turkey reconciliation - opinion
In an interview with Tert.am, President of the Yerevan-based Modus Vivendi Center Ara Papayan shared his expectations of Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu’s upcoming visit to Yerevan.
A source at Armenia’s Foreign Ministry has told Aravot that Armenia has developed a new road map for normalizing the Armenia-Turkey relations and submitted it directly to Ahmet Davutoglu through secret channels. Can such an initiative be expected from Armenia after all this hustle and bustle over the Customs Union and EU deals?
I do consider that possible because we have seen things of the kind before, but I don’t think it reasonable. Experience shows that whenever there are initiatives from Yerevan, they are never thoroughly and fully considered. It is sad to mention that all the steps which Armenia takes in the run-up to 2015 [Armenian Genocide centennial] pursue only one purpose: to rule out pressures on Turkey. So ours must join the game; otherwise it is sure to prove negative for us.
Is what you say a hint that the Armenia-Turkey relations cannot remain unsettled; that we need a solution but not until 2015?
It is possible to do that before 2015 as well, but the question is, on what grounds?. For instance, the latest comments by Deputy FM Shavarsh Kocharyan –saying that Turkey had better ratify the Zurich protocols – clearly demonstrate that it might be harmful for us. That’s an anchor for normalizing relations with Turkey, which is unacceptable. It is possible to head towards normalization before 2015, but for me, normalization means a protection of interests, not a waiver. I repeat, if the Zurich protocols are the issue, there is nothing good for us as they will bring no good, apart from creating problems for the Armenian manufacturer.
What statements do you expect Davutoglu to make?
My opinion is that Davutoglu wishes to refresh the illusion over the alleged Armenia-Turkey protocols.I think the statements will be made in the same spirit as before, but they will, of course, be based on very diplomatic terms. So their well-known three demands (recognition of borders, refusal to recognize the Armenian Genocide and settlement of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict) were voiced literally a fortnight ago when Turkey reiterated their position. So now that they have received what they wanted – as far as the first two points are concerned – they must try to strengthen [their position] on Karabakh. We are unfortunately starting to lose ground at that point because our intention to accede to the [Eurasian] Customs Union deprives us from the West’s assistance. Russia has not been of any help to us by an large; it has once again clearly outlined for itself that that it has to be achieved in the frameworks of what they understand to be Azerbaijan’s territorial integrity.
And nonetheless, where do you think the assistance – if any at all – comes from? Is it from Armenia, Turkey or any other country or organization?
I do want to believe that the initiative should not come from Armenia but it is natural to think that the world force center may propose initiatives of the kind. That’s to their advantage. For Russia too, it is an advantageous option as it maintains quite positive relations with Turkey and has to try to make them more sustainable. As for the west, it approaches the issue from a different angle. Through the normalization of the Armenia-Turkey relations, they were hopeful to isolate Armenia from Russia but that is obviously out of the question today. The bad news for us is that those questions have to be considered and solved with Moscow, not u, and that seems to be what is going on now.
So do you mean the initiative comes from Moscow?
Such an initiative – if it exists at all – is not definitely ours, to my mind. It is Russia’s, in all likelihood. We would never have done anything of the kind on our own.
The unsettled Karabakh conflict was recently declared to have brought the West face to face with a fact of reality. I mean, they came to understand that the fact has disrupted the Armenia-Turkey move and Armenia’s association with the EU.
I don’t think that way. Even if the Karabakh conflict were settled, Russia would have never tolerated Armenia’s closer relations with the EU. Armenia’s sovereignty is not in Russia’s interests. What it needs is a situation that would make Armenia dependent on it in every respect. The Russians proved very consistent and smart at knitting the trap we are in today. The West will have nothing to lose if we do not sign the Association Agreement. We have what to lose. It isn’t as if the European Union market were opening for Armenia not the Armenian market for the EU.
As you have been a diplomat for many years, can you say if Davutoglu will be offered to visit the Genocide memorial? What does the protocol say about that at all?
What my memory tells me is that there were two cases of the kind, and both were rejected. But there is a delicate moment here. Davutoglu’s visit to Armenia is not part of the bilateral relations agenda; it is not a visit to Armenia. He is coming to attend the Black Sea Economic Cooperation’s session for which Yerevan has been selected a venue. As for just an apology, that will be no use in terms of eliminating the consequences.
Do you think he is likely to visit anyway? That sounds romantic perhaps, however …
No, he will not. That may be discussed but I am sure that the price will be the concession of several regions of Karabakh. The Turks pursue a very interesting diplomacy. Anything negotiated and given is considered theirs, and they move forward with that. The important thing for them is the Nagorno-Karabakh issue, so the Turks will declare Karabakh the price for normalizing the Armenia-Turkey relations.
Are you familiar with the so-called road map? Turkey publicly recognizes the fact of the Armenian Genocide and makes apologies to the Armenians around the world. It immediately opens the Armenia-Turkey border and establishes diplomatic relations with Armenia. Turkey manages later to propose peaceful efforts towards settling the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict and obtains the right to realize public programs aimed at overseeing the war rhetoric, preventing border incidents, withdrawing snipers and preparing societies for peace.
My forecast is right. I mean, if an Armenia-Turkey normalization process begins. implying Genocide recognition and opening of borders, Karabkh will be [the price] to be paid in return.









