Armenia had no message from the West to repeat Ukraine’s scenario – opinions

12:13 • 20.12.13

Armenia neither received a message from the West nor had a civil society accomplished enough to rebel against the authorities’ Russian integration efforts as did Ukraine, say Andrias Ghukasyan, a politician and Ani Kaghinyan, a civic activist.


In comments to Tert.am, they both agreed that Russia’s concessions to Ukraine - following crowded street protests and campaigns – were due to the unanimous efforts of both the civil society and the opposition parties.


Ghukasyan noted Armenia’s political context, which largely influenced the society’s behavior, is essentially different from that in Ukraine.


“The first difference is that it was clearly mentioned in Vilnius that no [association] agreement would be signed with [Ukrainian President Victor] Yanukovich. That was a very important message to the public, reflecting the West’s position,” he explained.


The second essential factor, according Ghukasyan, is the presence of pro-Western political forces in Ukraine, a fact which he said didn’t remain unnoticed by partners from the European People’s Party.


“Thirdly, the former presidents, who were not indifferent to Ukraine’s future, issued a joint statement. Hence, all the elements of the political system - both external and internal - did something to make the issue and the objective clear to the public. So people took to the street, demonstrating a high political and civic activeness,” the politician continued.


Ghukasyan said the absence of clear-cut messages to Armenia creates a kind of uncertainty not attracting the people to an active campaign.


“Why should the Republic of Armenia stand up for a struggle against the Customs Union if the People’s Party of Europe does not find it necessary? If we knew [there is a message from the West], we would take [to the streets]. The West said, in the person of different diplomats, that [President] Serzh Sargsyan’s decision is acceptable and clear, and that they don’t find he is placing the Armenian people on the wrong track,” he added.


Ghukasyan said the Armenian authorities are demonstrating a “colonial behavior”, failing to protect the nation’s interest. He said the people do not see any reason for an active campaign, with the opposition being very passive too.


As for civic activists, the politician said they did all their best in the present circumstances. “Everything possible was done. Protest actions were really held, but they could not expand beyond the existing political frameworks. Anyone who is concerned realizes the threats behind the choice,” he noted.


Commenting on the political situation in Armenia, Khaghinyan said that the world community’s support would have played an important role raising civic activeness in Armenia.


“Armenia is of no interest to either the US or Europe, or even Russia. So when the Armenian citizens stand up for a struggle, they do feel the lack of support. We must, of course, be self-organized at home, but the international community too, has to intervene when necessary, as is the case with Ukraine,” the activist noted.


She further stressed the importance of the authorities’ role in changing public moods. She said she doesn’t think that the authorities in Armenia feel responsibility for any step of theirs.


“We never found out what calculations the September 3 decision on joining the Customs Union stemmed from. That’s being kept secret to date. The authorities have isolated themselves from the society, and they do what they like. And, of course, they see the Ukrainian president’s achievements – a loan of 15 million Dollars plus a payoff of the 7 billion natural gas debt – with no concessions offered to Armenia. What’s even worse, they owned [the Armenian Governments] 20 percent share in [Hayrusgasard],” she noted.


The activist said the civil society in Armenia is not, on the other hand, very often committed to its real mission.


“International organizations give considerable sums to NGOs and civic movements in the form of grants, but most civic and non-governmental organizations enjoy simultaneously the Government’s sponsorship.


“I mean, they do not even conduct a proper monitoring to know what those people do and where they go. That’s why the short period wasn’t enough to create a civil society which could, in turn, develop a [civic] movement,” she concluded.