‘Youth Justice’ to apply to 20 life-termers in Armenia
The “Youth Justice” project, intended to exempt young felons from life sentence, is going to be incorporated into Armenia’s Criminal Code to apply to life termers aged 21 or under, says a member of the working group elaborating the proposal.
“It is planned to exclude life imprisonment for [individuals] aged 21 and under. Naturally, it will have a retroactive effect as a mitigating circumstance,” Ara Gabuzyan, a criminal law professor at the Yerevan State University, told Tert.am.
The proposed amendment to the Criminal Code will apply to about 21 young Armenian termers if enacted.
“The cases will be automatically revised, and it implies, that their punishment will be reduced to the maximum timeframes stipulated for in the Criminal Code,” said the specialist.
The problem of life imprisonment has 22 years’ history in Armenia.
Human right activists, together with Zaruhi Mezhlumyan, a public journalist in charge for the Armenian Innocence Project, have been conducting lobbying ever since to raise the age limit to 21, but the ice hasn’t broken yet.
In several European countries (Sweden, Germany, Belgium etc), felons not meeting the specified age limit criteria are not only exempted from life sentence but also convicted in accordance with norms envisaged for the underage.
Mezhlumyan says there are now 21 such young life-termers in Armenia, with 14 of them having been convicted for crimes committed during military service.
“I took up journalism three years ago, and we have observed blatant violations. In my articles, have repeatedly stressed the necessity of re-opening old criminal cases, calling for an individual revision, but [my demands met] stony indifference; none of the cases was revised,” she told Tert.am.
Mezhlumyan said a study of the cases, which she initiated later, were absolutely inadequate.
“For instance, a life imprisonment ruling was issued based on evidence obtained from a forensic-biological examination of a corpse; no expert examination of material evidence was conducted,” she said, bringing examples from the cases studied.
Mezhlumyan said the possibility of a judicial error is accepted even by countries having strongly enhanced judiciary systems. In countries like Armenia, where imperfection of the judiciary strikes the eye of even the authorities, it is pointless to talk about the percentage of such errors, said the journalist.
Innocence Project, which has voiced concern over the problem based on letters from convicts, has managed to have several cases revised after obtaining the results of DNA tests, as well as available material evidence.
In the United Kingdom, over 300 convicts sentenced for life or long-term imprisonment have returned to freedom after being acquitted. In 75 percent of those cases, rulings were issued based on witness evidence.
President of Armenian Helsinki Committee Avetik Ishkhanyan says a society demonstrating indifference to imprisoned people, is more likely to have a prejudiced opinion on those sentenced for life.
“What comes to mind by saying a ‘life-termer’ is that they may have committed an utterly grave crime, but no regard is paid to our judicial system,” he told our correspondent.
Ishkhanyan and other Armenian human rights activists say they don’t think it is right to return a life imprisonment verdict against a person accused of only one murder. With that purpose, they have submitted a proposal to different parliamentary factions.
Gabuzyan, as legal professional, considers the proposal wrong from the point of view of applying the legal technique. “Just imagine one person’s murder committed in strikingly brutal circumstances, such as dismembering him or her alive. Aren’t we supposed to envisage life imprisonment for that?”
Dwelling on the problem further, Gabuzyan said special criteria could be introduced to the Criminal Code to narrow courts’ chances of subjective manipulations.









