We have what we have – Armenia’s second president on Customs Union integration perspectives
In an interview with 2rd.am website, Armenia’s ex-president Robert Kocharyan addressed the possible impact of the Customs Union accession on Armenia.
According to him, any haste in this process of conciliating interests may have unfavorable consequences. Armenia should not have agreed to initialing an Association Agreement with the European Union in company with the GUAM member-states. It made the process take on additional geopolitical overtones.
Mr Kocharyan, what’s your opinion of Armenia’s decision to join the Russian-Belarusian-Kazakh Customs Union?
This is a subject of paramount important. But to understand it we have to make a comparative analysis of approaches to the customs policy in Russia and Armenia after the USSR’s collapse.
About Russia first:
Russia inherited the USSR’s enormous industrial potential – practically all the economic sectors, with a strong emphasis on the military-industrial complex. But that potential was not integrated with the world economy, with greater part of it focused on the domestic market and the former socialist camp. Oil and gas exports constituted 65% of the USSR’s exports. To protect its industry from more competitive imports, Russia applied high customs duties, and its domestic market enabled the industry to continue operating. The application of export duties and quotas to energy carriers enabled the government to keep the domestic prices, which would keep Russia’s economy fairly competitive. By the way, that allowed Russia to avoid an economic collapse similar to that in Armenia in the early 1990s. Now that Russia has joined the World Trade Organization (WTO), it is gradually revising its foreign trade rules for full integration with the world economy. It implies some short-term problems, but long-term benefits.
About Armenia:
We inherited serious industrial potential oriented to the USSR market, which had ceased to exist by that time. The domestic market for the industry was insignificant. The absence of a common border and railway communication with Russia thwarted all efforts to resume cooperation. The sad situation in a number of economic sectors in Russia in the mid-1990s was not at all a reason for optimism. After the USSR’s collapse, a significant part of Armenia’s industry turned export-oriented and lost the traditional markets and partners. So applying customs duties to many industries, except for agriculture and processing, did not make any sense. Other instruments for protection could be applied. On top of all, Armenia’s blockade and higher transportation costs for practically all the products. So, in the mid-1990s, Armenia’s government liberalized foreign trade and Armenia joined the WTO in 2003 to speed up its integration with the world economy.
Thus, Armenia and Russia had developed different approaches to the customs policies for quite a long time. And those approaches laid the basis of our country’s customs legislation. And because the Customs Union’s approaches lies upon the Russian Federation’s Customs Code, a question arises as to what problem Armenia is solving for its economy by raising the customs duties to the Russian level, and whether it will manage to revise its approaches without shocks.
I don’t share the officials’ optimism in this respect, because the economy bears an inert character, and its re-adaptation will take a long time. Certain forms of business will, in all likelihood, improve their positions, while other will die. We need an in-depth analysis, open to business to forecast all the possible impacts on all types of goods on the CU countries’ markets. Businessmen and farmers must know what branches [of economy] a likely to create difficulties for them and vice versa – where they can increase their chances. It will also hel[ banks and credit organizations to manage their financial resources in a more effective manner and with less risks.
Besides, the European Union will, in all likelihood, revise the GSP+ system with Armenia, as the EU countries’
ambassadors also hint the issue. Questions will arise also with regard to the change of customs duties with the WTO, which we are unlikely to avoid. That will lead to the implementation of reciprocal measure. As to how it will impact Armenia’s econo,y and the attractiveness of our countries long-term investments, it’s hard to predict that now.
Another question which has been raised is the increase in the prices of products imported from countries beyond the CU borders. Considering the dominance of such products on the consumer market and the trade deficit level in Armenia, zedeql zith essentiql volumes here. The formula is very simple; once you raise the customs duty, the prices of goods increase in shops. Or the goods are exchanged with equivalent products from the Customs Union, if they are at all produced there at all. The Belarusian meat and dairy products, for instance, may sell for a cheaper price in Armenia, and so will our wine and brandy in Belarus. As to how the competition will affect our cattle-breeding, that’s a matter of time. The prices for the household equipment, electronics and machines imported from those countries will go up in part if no corresponding exceptions are made. Everything is possible to calculate and predicts, and those calculations have to be accessible to public. The essential increase in prices can be restrained only through the introduction of an extensive exception list and through a harmonization of the gradual decrease with the customs duties. And that depends on the outcomes of the talks with all the CU member states, which will mutually propose their requirements. That’s a process of coordinating interests, so haste may result to undesired consequences.









