Ukraine’s plan to leave CIS dramatized – debate

17:03 • 27.05.14

The Ukrainian authorities’ plan to suspend the country’s membership in the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS) is a bit dramatized, an Armenian expert has said, considering the union of former Soviet republics an exhausted structure.


“It is clear to all that the CIS is no longer the one-time very important union, so Ukraine’s suspension [of membership] is not a big problem at all,” Sergey Minasyan, the head of the Caucasus Institute’s Political Science Department, told a televised spacebridge on Thursday.


Gagik Harutyunyan, the Noravank Scientific Research Foundation’s director, said for his part that it is now important for the CIS member states to think over new formats of cooperation. “The CIS format has exhausted itself, so we have to find a new one. It is important to switch over to a new format and thus correct the mistakes that existed in the frameworks of previous cooperation,” he noted.


The expert said he feels that it is now possible to create more practicable and better prepared union.


Alexander Gusev, the CIS Strategic Development Center’s director who had joined the spacebridge from Moscow, said he expects Ukraine’s decision to be a heavy loss for both the CIS and the country itself. “Ukraine will suffer a loss; so will the CIS. One doesn’t have to be an economist to understand what is going on in Ukraine” he said, adding that a non-membership in the CIS would offer neither political nor economic advantages to the country.


The expert further referred to the Russian leader’s remark that the country could have a greater role in the formation of the Eurasian Economic Union. “Ukraine’s role should not be undervalued in political terms; its economic role is also great in the CIS frameworks. Ukraine accounts for one eighth of the product turnover among the CIS member states,” he added.


Denis Denisov, the head of the CIS Institute’s Ukrainian branch, said the suspension of membership would create problems for the other member countries as well given that Ukraine is a state party to scores of interstate agreements. “For Ukraine, it would mean a suspension of membership in the CIS area. I think [President-elect Pyotr] Poroshenko is a pragmatic personality to weigh the information and stop pushing ahead with those policies,” he added.