Constitutional reforms and switchover to new election model: opinions diverge in Karabakh
Constitutional reforms proposing a switichover to a parliamentary government and a 100% proportional representation voting system are also on the agenda of the Nagorno-Karabakh government but not on the level of public debates.
Speaking to Tert.am, the country’s prime minister, Ara Harutyunyan, refrained from commenting on his expectations, considering the timing too early for personal opinions. "The parliament periodically conducts debates, but that’s absolutely unrelated to the reforms under way in Armenia,” he said.
Armenian politicians backing the semi-presidential and presidential government models have always argued that a powerful presidential institute is necessary for countries facing frozen conflicts. The same thesis also applies to Nagorno-Karabakh.
Harutyunyan, who heads the Free Motherland party, said the government model in Nagorno-Karabakh also used to be parliamentary before the war. “When we won the war, there wasn’t a presidential institute; we had a parliamentary [government]. I can also bring the example of Israel which is a parliamentary country and is always at war. But let us not restrict ourselves with that,” he said.
Hayk Khanumyan, an opposition politician who heads the National Renaissance party, expressed his disagreement to the parliamentary model. “Artsakh was a parliamentary state from the start of war; decision-making was a difficult process then, so only the centralization of government helped overcome the crisis,” he explained.
Khanumyan didn’t agree that the choice of government model is crucial for a country’s democracy level. As for the 100 percent proportional representation system, he said the model is advantageous for political parties with limited financial resources. “I think that the 100 percent proportional representation weakens the representativeness principle in parliament. So the parliament is an open institution which, apart from legislative and oversight functions, also exercises the functions of a representative body. And I think that the people have a right to have representatives in the legislative body by electing single-seat lawmakers,” he added.
Vahan Badasyan, a cross-bencher of the Nagorno-Karabakh National Assembly, said the legislative package hasn’t been submitted to the parliament yet. But his approach to the proposed electoral reform was positive. “To make the country democratic, we do need the 100 percent proportional system. I agree to that,” he said.
As for the other proposal, Badasyan said he prefers a government model ensuring a balance between the different branches of power.
he thinks that it is better for the different branches of government to maintain balance.









