Armenia has constitution without constitutionality - opinions
Since 1995, Armenia has been celebrating July 5 as the day of the national constitution.
Nineteen years ago today, the country adopted its basic law in a nationwide referendum. Subsequent amendments were passed in 2005. A concept of new constitutional reforms is now under preparation.
Larisa Alaverdyan, a former ombudsman of Armenia who now heads the NGO Against Illegal Arbitrariness, says she believes that both the 1995 Constitution and the 2005 amendments were passed in somewhat suspicious circumstances.
“The society remained with the belief that the Constitution’s adoption was rigged as were the 1995 [parliamentary] elections. It is a very regrettable fact that leaves its imprint on what we call constitutionality,” she told Tert.am, adding that she considers the concept as demanded and actual now as it was in 1995.
Alaverdyan noted that despite all the shortcomings, the Armenian society has developed a positive understanding of the Constitution. “The declarative – if not non-functioning – constitution has enabled the the society’s most active groups to gain experience, especially after the 2005 [amendments] that broadened the mechanisms of administering justice through the Constitutional Court,” she added.
Gagik Jhangiryan, an opposition MP (Armenian National Congress) and a former military prosecutor who was involved in the drawing up of the 1995 Constitution, said he doesn’t think the constitutional norms are being ignored in Armenia.
“The Constitution defines the guarantees of human rights protection, but what can the people do if they are not enforced?” he said, when asked to comment on the civic campaigns that often see the different groups of the society standing up for the protection of what is widely believed to be constitutional rights.
Chairman of the Helsinki Committee Avetik Ishkhanhyan said absolutely all constitutions have two basic parts despite the different philosophies.
“The first part is a declarative one which sets out prospects, provisions regarding human rights etc. If we approach the question from that angle, [the constitution] of more autocratic countries may have a better wording,” he said. “Hence the less declarative part, which stipulates the mechanisms of government formation is much more essential. So [the important thing] is to really be a democratic, legal and social state rather than to be declared as such.”
Ishkhanyan noted that some constitutions do not stipulate for the separation of powers to ensure guarantees for an independent judiciary and local self-government, whereas many others propose the medieval monarchic government model (semi-presidential system).
“From that point of view, our constitution reflects the monarchic philosophy despite the 2005 amendments. It proposes an authoritarian dependence of the entire government system upon the president. And that is why our society often makes references to the declarative parts of the constitution,” he said.
Asked whether he thinks constitutional reforms are now necessary for Armenia, Iskhkahnyan he finds a change of philosophy more important. “It has to be a public demand to make the authorities to adopt such changes based on a consensus. What has been initiated today, in the current atmosphere of distrust, gives me the confidence that the authorities do not wish to make a separation of powers,” he added.
Artak Zeynalyan, a co-founder of the local NGO, Rule of Law, said reforms he finds reforms very important despite the absence of a public demand. But he was unsure whether the proposed amendments are in any way linked to Armenia’s plans to join the Eurasian Customs Union.









