Karabakh needs recognition by subjects of international law – Armenian expert

11:35 • 17.09.14

Nagorno-Karabakh’s recognition by non-subjects of international law marks only a moral victory for the country, according to Ara Papyan, the director of the Yerevan based analytical center Modus Vivendi.


“We have only moral victories in such cases, but it adds nothing to Artsakh’s [Nagorno-Karabakh’s] security,” he told Tert.am, commenting on the recently adopted resolitions.


It comes after Martin Garitano, the governor of the Basque Gipuzkoa province, said at a meeting with the Nagorno-Karabakh foreign minister last week that they recognize Artsakh as an independent country.


Earlier, the California Senate overwhelmingly adopted a resolution encouraging the people pf Karabakh to continue the efforts towards developing a free and independent nation.


Papyan recommended considering two basic aspects in the process: the legal and the political. “When we approach the Nagorno-Karabakh recognition from the political standpoint, there is naturally no recognition here. Under international law, recognition is possible if it has been declared by a subject which is already recognized. What we have today – whether a US state or a Spanish province – are not subjects of international law; hence they cannot recognize [a country],” he explained.


The analyst noted that a close look into the Basque parliament’s resolution would reveal that it only expresses support to the Nagorno-Karabakh people’s right to self-determination.


“And because no state has yet recognized the Nagorno-Karabakh independence, it cannot be considered recognized. Recognition is within the competence of a federal authority,” he said, considering the recent measures politically positive for Karabakh.


Asked whether he doesn’t think that those “recognitions” might entrap the Armenian Genocide recognition efforts, the expert replied, “Given that scores of US states have recognized it without a result, that’s already something like a trap, because recognition is aimed at making them a subject of international law and committing themselves to its principles. And that means that a state’s defense and its borders cannot be violated under the threat of force. Under the UN Charter, a country has a right to self-defense; hence, recognition is not an end in itself; it has a meaning."