Armenia has chances to return historical property – expert opinion
Armenia theoretically has all the chances to apply to the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) to demand the return of a historical royal residence and land property in Sis (Cilica Kingdom), says an international law expert.
“Exercising the right to restitution is a key requirement for membership in the European Union, so it should help reinstate the violated rights and historical justice. The requirement also applies to Turkey which has recently taken certain steps in that direction. The general procedure requires that the problems be resolved inside a state; hence Catholicos Aram I’s statement expressing an intention to apply to international courts for returning the residence and land property in Sis is part of that requirement,” Vigen Kocharyan, Head of the Yerevan State University’s Chair of European and International Law, told the state news agency Armenpress.
As of 2012, Turkey returned 143 out of the 1,328 items of immovable property seized from the Armenian foundations of Istanbul.
Kocharyan said that he finds that applying to the ECHR would be a good chance in case Turkey fails to satisfy the Armenian side’s appeal on the domestic courts' level.
“The ECHR admissibility criteria require exhaustion of all the domestic remedies. So the state has to settle the matter internally. But a failure to reach a positive outcome offers a good chance for applying to the ECHR to reinstate the violated provisions of the [European] Convention [on Human Rights],” he explained.
Noting that the ECHR rulings are based on the principle of case law, the expert said he doesn’t overestimate the possible consequences in case of a negative ruling. He noted further that a positive conclusion would be a serious signal for the Turkish government in terms of taking more active steps.









