Etienne Mahchupian seems to be far from Armenians’ grieves - opinions

11:26 • 05.11.14

The recent statements made by Etienne Mahchupian, the newly-appointed senior advisor to Turkey’s prime minister, demonstrate that he is estranged from the common problems and grieves shared by the Armenians worldwide, says an Armenian orientalist. 


“The statements he has made since becoming a senior advisor to the Turkish premier, as well as the other statements made before give rise to many questions. He announced, for example, that Armenian and Diaspora are in conflicts over the recognition and the 100th anniversary of Genocide. This is definitely wrong, as being an Armenian, he is obliged to know that this is the kind of problem over which the Armenians cannot be split. And the same was later repeated by the country’s president, [Recep Tayyip] Erdogan,” Ruben Safrastyan, Director of the National Academy's Institute of Oriental Studies, told Tert.am.


Citing Ermenihaber.am, a Turkish-language news website covering the developments in Armenia, the Armenian service of RFE/RL (Azatutyun) reported Mahchupian as saying recently that visiting Armenia on April 24, 2015 is a gesture which requires numerous other new gestures. “If those gestures are made, the situation may mature, and the president may go to Armenia. But if we are realistic, I don’t find it possible. As Armenia is expected to demonstrate an unusually tough stance in 2015, Turkey will not make that gesture,” he was quoted as saying.


Mahchupian’s approaches give ground to think that he is on the wrong track, Safrastyan said, addressing his remark. “Erdogan’s [decision] whether or not to come to Armenia has nothing to do with Armenia’s position. If he comes, he will do so to raise his country’s honor a little bit; that’s not for Armenia,” he noted.

Turkologist Vahram Ter-Matevosyan had earlier told Tert.am that he doesn’t expect either positive or negative developments from Mahchupian’s appointment. He warned against attempts of searching for hidden conspiracies behind the move or, on the contrary, getting very enthusiastic.


Commenting on Mahchupian’s recent statements, the expert said he knows that the Turkish political system would never allow someone with pro-Armenian positions to be appointed to a senior discretionary government post.

“That man’s activities will be pro-Turkish, first of all; all the rest is a matter of comment. He cannot do anything beyond that framework; he was appointed there for specific political activities. And his activities do not have to have anything in common with the Armenian factor. Hence it is better to avoid great expectations not to be disappointed later. This is a process which we must use as an opportunity,” he added.


As for Erdogan’s possible visit to Armenia, the expert agreed that it isn’t reasonable to jump conclusions months before the Genocide centennial. “Armenia adopted the tough rhetoric in 2010, so there’s nothing new about it. And however tough Armenia’s rhetoric, Turkey is to blame for it. As to whether or not the viewpoint expressed is realistic, I can add several factors to that, including the fact that Turkey will be on the threshold of elections. So if there is a will, everything else is of secondary importance,” he added.