Nagorno-Karabakh: The country that did not exist – Le Vif L'Express

16:33 • 24.11.14

Twenty years after the end of a bloody conflict, the Republic of Nagorno-Karabakh, mostly populated by ethnic Armenians, still has not been recognised by the UN.


The numbers of deathly incidents with Azerbaijan keep increasing, a fact that delays the perspective of a solution.


By François Janne d’Othée


A fine mist covers Stepanakert, the capital of Nagorno-Republic – this Republic populated by a majority of ethnic Armenians that has never been recognised by any UN member State. It is the weekend. Furtive shadows cross the almost empty avenues. The rather poor vehicle fleet did not get rid yet of its Soviet stock, particularly of roaring Ladas with tinted windows. “We also have traffic jams, at around noon and 4 pm”, a public servant explains with humour to the one who would not have realised yet that Stepanakert is a capital city. The coffee shops are almost empty, except for some young people wearing black leather jackets. Small yellow buses ride back and forth through the town, bringing a little touch of colour. They even gave rise to the first demonstration since the 1988 protestation against Moscow’s government: about seventy urban citizens opposed to the increased price of bus tickets, from 70 to 100 Armenian drams (from 0,13 to 0,20 euros).


Armenia’s prudence


Surrounded by tree-covered mountains, Stepanakert is without any doubt the only capital city in the world without an air route. However, the city has a brand new airport since 2011, aiming at linking it to Armenia’s capital, Yerevan, attached to its Christian identity as much as Nagorno-Karabakh. There is currently only one winding road connecting between the two sister-cities, a seven-hour travel for only 330 kilometres. Since its brand-new re-opening, the airport was never used for one simple reason: the Azerbaijani authorities, a country with a Muslim majority, have threatened to shoot down any plane, even a commercia aircraft, that would get close to it. The reason: a conflict remaining from the Soviet period between Yerevan and Baku, the latter claiming this territory that is populated by 150 000 souls and three times smaller than Belgium in size. In the 1990’s, 30 000 people have lost their lives in the fighting. The scars of the Azerbaijani bombardments remain visible in town and up to the heights of Shushi.


Whereas war officially came to an end in 1994, sporadic incidents keep erupting along the frontline and are even increasing since this summer. On 12 November, Azerbaijani forces shot down a helicopter. “Each new casualty delays the solution of the conflict”, Ashot Ghoulian, the President of the local Parliament explains to Le Vif/L’express, concerned about Baku’s flight intervention. “After all, we could also shoot down their planes using our air corridors. But we do not want to play this barbarian game”.


In order not to renew hostilities, Armenia refrained from recognising the young republic officially. This is a pure political gamesmanship, as every issue goes through Yerevan that provides passports to citizens of the enclave to allow them to travel, and add the Armenian code to all the products to be exported. The national flag itself is a symbol: identical to the Armenian flag, though with a crack on the right side. “It means that we are separated and deeply united at the same time”, the director of the Armenian branch of European Friends of Armenia, Hovhannes Grigoryan, explains.


A conflict that is not really frozen


At the rear of a parking lot is the War Museum and a keeper has been kind enough to open for us. In its small space, we discovered a real assortment of weapons, sometimes home-made ones, uniforms and various objects, such as ancient typewriters, accordions that used to soothe nights of vigil, or Islamic scarfs taken from bodies of Chechen militiamen. The walls are covered with hundreds of pictures showing war martyrs. This was yesterday. “We thought that we were done with war at the 21st century, but that was not true”, Arayik Harutyunyan stated, alongside his assistant, a former soldier who became blind because of shrapnel. “The conflict is not really frozen here because it can evolve at any moment, in one direction or the other”.


“Do tensions between Moscow and the West make the situation worse?”, I ask. “The impact of superpowers is not that important”, the Prime Minister notes. “Russia, providing us our equipment, plays of course a big role, but its interests sometimes enter into contradictions with the ones of the region.” “What about the European Union?” “The Union shows complete indifference to the issue”, the Prime Minister says. “I am forced to note that Azerbaijani oil sometimes weights more than everything else”.


A Christian island


The Prime Minister’s almost ancient mobile phone rings. It is time to leave, under escort, to a national event in the Hadrout province: the pickle festival, where one can taste regional products and try the local vodka. The entire government made the trip, even the President. The local Archbishop, Mr Pargev, with his black cap and thick beard, was also present. Questioned about the potential jihadist threat on this isolated Christian Armenia in the middle of a Muslim ocean, he explains: “We are used to this since hundreds of years. Though, international terrorism is a bomb for all of us, including the Muslims. That is why we all have to keep dialogue alive with our neighbours”. However, none of these dignitaries was invited to the negotiations that were taking place in Paris at the same time, between Presidents Sargsyan (Armenia) and Aliyev (Azerbaijan), gathered by the French President François Hollande.


How does such a country succeed to satisfy its basic needs? On the road leading to Hadrout, signs display the names of generous patrons who financed sections of it or hospitals. For everything else, the state collects its own taxes to fund its budget, including the military one – one of the highest in the world. A fundraiser is organised every year to finance concrete projects. As the country is not recognised, no European NGO is based there. “Only the Americans help us directly to finance demining activities, hospitals, water distribution systems, …” Ashot Ghoulian notes. It is better to be upfront: Azerbaijan mentions on its governmental website that visas will be refused to anyone who penetrated into Nagorno-Karabakh via Armenia.


The democratic asset


In order to prove its honour and reputation, Nagorno-Karabakh puts forward its democratic pedigree. The latest elections, aiming at renewing the 33 seats at the Parliament, were transparent. “The members of Parliament are always unanimous about defence policy and external affairs, because we know the price we have paid”, Armine, a civil servant, explains. In the entrance hall, photos of the eleven members of parliament killed during the war are displayed. In terms of justice, the authorities insist on appearing above reproach. Since 27 October, two Azerbaijani citizens are in custody for having illegally crossed the border with weapons and for murdering a young man. “Even if the State is not recognised, judiciary procedures stay legal because they correspond with international standards in this domain”, Larisa Alaverdyan, from the Foundation against Law Violation, underlines.


In the meantime, Karabakh is proud to claim a low level of crime, one of the lowest in the world. It is unfortunate for them that this is not displayed in any international ranking.