Armenia’s government has to decide between health tourism and mine development – debate

14:28 • 06.05.15

The Aarhus Center has organized a round table discussion on the Amulsar gold bearing quartz field development project.

Nazeli Vardanyan, director of the Forests of Armenia NGO, presented violations of law during the expert examination, referring to Article 10 of the Law on Lake Sevan, which prohibits environmentally damaging production in the area.

“Amulsar development will cause environmental damage to Lake Sevan. However, in defiance of the law, Armenia’s Ministry of Nature Protection approved the expert examination results,” she said.

Moreover, any shocks caused by blasts may cause water loss in Jermuk. The examination body also acted in defiance of Armenia’s water code. The examination results were approved in defiance of the Armenian government’s statement on plans to develop Jermuk as a tourist center.

“The government must decide between developing either health tourism or mining industry because doing both is incompatible,” Ms Vardanyan said.

The activist pointed out to a violation of Article 10 of Armenia’s Constitution (right to property).

“The body conducting the expert examination was not guided by the above laws, so it could not have issued a positive conclusion. Hence the conclusion is illegal,” she said, stressing the need of further strong efforts.

Seyran Minasyan, an expert also attending the news conference, said one of the remarks addressed the dissipation of the mine dust, which spread to the coasts of Lake Sevan. She underlined the need of state efforts to conduct a new site examination.

The environmentalist Inga Zarafyan also expressed her skepticism of the positive finding.

Responding to her remark, a representative from the Ministry of Nature Protection, Arthur Minasyan, said the report was based on positive conclusiond by three community governors and the commission tasked with exploring the environmental threats to Lake Sevan.

“The Ministry hasn’t received a negative conclusion,” she said, adding that no opinions were left unanswered.

Addressing the problem, Vice President of Didien International Didie Fohlen, stressed the importance of the public debates as a key platform allowing all parties to express their opinions.

The environmentalist Levon Galstyan warned of the environmental hazards of the mine’s exploitation.  “Those who say that the ‘mine eating’ activities are common in many states had better open the maps to compare the countries,” he said.