Acknowledging genocide should make responsibility possible - Stuart J. D. Schwartzstein
As many readers no doubt know, April 24 was the date which marked the centenary of the Armenian genocide. I use that term deliberately: with the exception of one historian at Princeton (but with ties to the Turkish Government) I know of no serious scholar of the late Ottoman period or of what, we call now genocide – the deliberate murder of a people – who does not believe that the killing of about a million and a half Armenians in 1915-16 should not be called genocide. Sadly, the government of Turkey continues to refuse to admit that that “great catastrophe” was genocide. A number of governments and legislatures have done so, but the US Government, not wanting to strain relations with Turkey, has not – even though when President Obama was a senator, he did so and even though President Reagan also did. The Pope also very recently declared that the murder of the Armenians constituted a case of genocide, leading to the Turkish government recalling its ambassador to the Holy See. The Government of Israel, like the US Government, has not formally acknowledged the deaths as genocide out of concern for relations with Turkey – although many Israelis (including the editors of the Jerusalem Post) have used that term. For Jews there is an additional aspect: some believe that widespread indifference to that great tragedy influenced Hitler and the Nazis in their genocide of Jews. Supposedly Hitler said,” Who remembers the Armenians?”
In contrast to the willful denial – one might say obtuseness – of Turkey’s president, Recep Tayyep Erdogan, and the Turkish government, the Germans have, as we know, not only admitted guilt for the Holocaust, but one German president, Richard von Weizsaecker, who died in January of this year, was passionate, honest and eloquent. Some readers may remember the speech he gave to the Bundestag on May 8, 1987, after Reagan’s ill-advised visit to the cemetery at Bitburg. In his speech (which he himself wrote) marking the 40th anniversary of the end of WWII von Weizsaecker noted that that day “is above all a day of remembering what people had to suffer” and “We commemorate in particular the six million Jews who were murdered in German concentration camps.” He went on to say: “The Jewish people remember and will always remember. As human beings, we seek reconciliation. Precisely for this reason we must understand that there can be no reconciliation without memory.” Richard von Weizsaecker’s eloquent speech should not be forgotten and it would behoove the Turkish government to learn from the Germans who, in acknowledging responsibility for the genocidal murder of six million Jews with great sorrow, have made reconciliation possible.
Stuart J. D. Schwartzstein has worked as a foreign-affairs professional for more than 30 years, having served in the Defense and State Departments in a wide range of capacities, including as a diplomat, an analyst, negotiator, advisor and planner. He has also held positions in several think-tanks, including the Center for Strategic and International Studies(CSIS) in Washington D.C. His work has ranged broadly, both geographically and in subject matter, including defense industrial cooperation with European allies, technology transfer and export control issues, "information revolution" issues, encryption policy, international science and technology policy, chemical and biological weapons issues, refugee policy, Horn of Africa issues, relations with European allies, ASEAN countries and the Middle East. While at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (1992-96), he did a good deal of work on Iraq issues, particularly focusing on human rights violations by Saddam Hussein and his regime. In 2004, he served in the Coalition Provisional Authority in Baghdad as an advisor to the Minister for Science & Technology and to the president of the Iraqi National Academy of Sciences. He has continued to follow events in Iraq and has maintained contact with a number of Iraqi friends, including several in senior Iraqi government positions, as well as officials and experts in the US. Mr Schwartzstein is currently an independent consultant based in Washington, D.C.









