Political stability clause crucial point in Armenia’s draft constitution – Venice Commission member

15:41 • 25.08.15

The political stability clause enshrined in the draft text of Armenia’s new constitution is a crucial point in the document, according to Christoph  Grabenwarter, a member of the Venice Commission.


The European official made the statement at a debate with representatives of civil society representatives and poltiicians in Yerevan, as she was asked by the Prosperous Armenia party’s leader to comment on Article 89.4 (structure and procedures of electing the National Assembly) of the proposed draft.  Naira Zohrabyan was particularly concerned over what she called the monopoly granted to the political majority under the draft clause in question.


“Against the experience of the constitution all over Europe, the Venice Commission, in all its  opinions, considers that political stability is an aim, a legitimate aim of constitution-making,” he said.


The second point, according to the Commission member, is the various ways of establishing stability. “The conditions of establishing stability vary from country to country. And the answers have to vary from country to country. This is the point where our task meets the political scene of a specific country, because the constitution’s goal is to make the choice if it is within the goals of the national actors. We have expressed concerns on the second draft; we have basically made it clear, and I think we got the common understanding that there are in particular two problems that have to be addressed at the outset,” he said, adding stressing the need of a shorter wording for the clause on the one hand and ruling out mechanisms that would impose only one method of guaranteeing stability on the other.


Grabenwarter  said that the legislative authorities should be given the chance of making a choice, adding that the requirement should be also a  message for constitutional reforms commission to push it to a further action.