European Court had no right to set Swiss national legal framework to its discretion - Sarkis Shahinian
In an interview with Tert.am, Sarkis Shahinian, Honorary President of the Switzerland-Armenia Association (SAA), which is defending Switzerland’s position in the Perinçek v.Switzerland case, commented on the ECHR Grand Chamber judgment in the case of Perinçek v. Switzerland and noted that the ECHR had no right to restrict the Swiss law to its discretion.
Mr Shahinian, what is the assessment of the ECHR judgment by the Armenian community in Switzerland and by your organization?
Very negative. And the most important is that the social and legal grounds for the Court’s knowledge and judgment are very weak. Being unable to consider denial of the Armenian Genocide equal to stirring up hatred is one of the lowest results that shows us the reality we are living in.
The Court found that the Swiss courts’ rulings against Perinçek were in defiance of the right to freedom of speech. What is your opinion?
In short, the problem is that, I think, the Court had no right to set the framework of Swiss national laws to its discretion – in a way it actually did. Because all those learning what happened in Switzerland, that is a fact, a reality, that it is a Swiss, not a European. And if at three legal levels Switzerland considered a possibility of inciting hatred and details of denial and premeditation, there arises a question of our trust of such a court of human rights.
According to the ECHR judgment, “it had not been necessary, in a democratic society, to subject the applicant to a criminal penalty in order to protect the rights of the Armenian community at stake in the case.” Does it mean Switzerland has to amend the law criminalizing the denial of the Armenian Genocide? Will France have to as well?
I can only speak of Switzerland. First of all, it is obvious that Switzerland’s law criminalizing the denial of the Armenian Genocide cannot continue as it has to date. Secondly, France has no law protecting Armenians’ dignity in the context of denial of the Armenian Genocide.
That is, Switzerland has to amend its law.
I have not said anything like this. It must not be amended nor must it be applied in the same format. The legislative body has to decide what to do. And Switzerland has to decide on whether it should honor such a convention (the European Convention on Human Rights – ed.) or not because its fundamental rights are unprotected.
Did you expect such a judgment by the ECHR? May be it is more good than bad.
I expected people to do their business. But they did not.
In your opinion, what is the reason for the ECHR judgment? Did not almost all European structures – the European Union, Council of Europe and other bodies – launch a triumphant campaign of condemnation of the Armenian Genocide after the Pope had condemned it?
I cannot comment because the reality is surpassing our expectations. The Court did not at all consider the legal grounds for recognition of the Armenian Genocide.









