ECHR judgment in Perincek case victory for Armenia – Amal Clooney

18:10 • 16.10.15

Amal Clooney, the world-class lawyer who represented Armenia in the Perincek vs Switzerland case, hails the ECHR Grand Chamber’s judgment delivered Thursday. In an interview with the Public Television of Armenia (H1 TV), the Lebanese-British lawyer, who formerly represented the interests of Wikileaks’ Julian Assange and  Canadian-Egyptian journalist Mohamed Fahmy, said she finds the decision a real victory for the Armenian side.


The full interview, conducted by the H1 TV Channel’s Lilit Sedrakyan, is presented below:


First of all, what’s your reaction to the European Court’s judgment?

Well, we are very happy with the judgment; it’s a victory for Armenia. You remember, Lilit, Armenia was neither a plaintiff nor a defendant in this case. Armenia was a third party that intervened in the case, along with Turkey. And it did so for one reason: because the lower court’s judgment had, in three paragraphs, cast doubt on the reality of the Armenian Genocide.  It cast doubt on whether or not the massacres of 1915 really constituted genocide, and it used a language that was, frankly, insulting to the Armenian community. It said that those events were somehow not able to be objectively proved or did not land themselves to a definitive conclusion. So we were very concerned, obviously, about that language; we went to the court to argue that in leaking out what should be done now, the Grand Chamber should make sure that they didn’t repeat that and say that that wouldn’t stand as a record of what the European Court of Human Rights has to say on the matter. So these are the arguments, and in the judgment, we won. The Court said that those findings by the lower court were inappropriate. So, ten of the judges said that they should never discuss the point at all; it was outside of its jurisdiction, which is the point we also made in our arguments, and another seven judges said that the Armenia Genocide is a clearly established historical fact. We are obviously very pleased that that’s what happened, and that’s why the judgment today is a victory for Armenians.


What exactly did the European Court decide?


The European Court decided that Perincek’s speeches should not be criminalized, because they didn’t rise to the level of a speech that is going to incite a racial hatred or violence in the country in which they were made – which was Switzerland, and which is actually an encouraging decision in the perspective of freedom of expression, because the Court should be concerned with any country’s laws that make speech a crime. And it’s, obviously, understandable that the Court wants to be very careful about ensuring that states only criminalize speech only in most extreme circumstances.  This finding is not really something that Armenia needs to be concerned with; people who talk about the Armenian Genocide are not being prosecuted in the courts of Yerevan. They are, however, being prosecuted in the courts in Turkey. And it is interesting that today - in the aftermath of the judgment - Turkey’s former foreign minister spoke to Aljazeera and said, ‘Oh, Turkey celebrates the judgment, because it respects freedom of expression.’ The reality is that in all the cases that have come before the court - up to 2014  - there have been 591 findings of violations of freedom of expression in the Court, and almost half of those are violations by Turkey. So it’s over 200 violations by Turkey, and the next was Austria with 32. And lower down the list, you have Russia with 26 violations. So the record before the Court is clear, and really what we hope is that Turkey really is paying a close attention to the judgment today, and that Turkey will embrace this high standard for freedom of expression that has been set, so that journalists like Hrant Dink are no longer prosecuted by Turkey’s courts for insulting Turkishness or insulting the Turkish state.


Thank you, Amal. And do you have any final words for the Armenian people?


Well, I would just say it was a true honor to be able to represent Armenia in this case. And looking back, I am sure that the Armenians don’t care much for what Mr Perincek will say. I think that if we look at the issues as a hole, we might say Armenians care for what the Pope will think. And we know that the Pope came out and said that this was a genocide, and President Obama, before becoming a president, said that it was a genocide. So you may have Turkey continue to deny that reality but they can no longer – after today’s judgment – point to a decision of the European Court of Human Rights to support that view. I think Turkey’s continued denials are regrettable, and they are going to impede or slow the ability for the communities to come together and reconcile their differences. But I am pleased, and I am honored to have been able to play a part in correcting the record, at least from the perspective of the Court’s today.