Gyumri murder trial: Court rejects motion to replace judge despite plaintiffs' strong call (updated)

17:33 • 18.01.16

The legal successors of the seven-member Avetisyan family, who brutally murdered in Gyumri in January last year, on Monday submitted a motion, demanding the withdrawal of the judge responsible for the proceeding.


At the hearing on Monday, Lusine Sahakyan, a representative of a legal successor, claimed that the judge’s behavior was far from impartial.


“You cannot be unbiased. You commit violations which are impermissible. That doesn’t mean that you are not well-aware of the [Criminal Procedure] Code; you certainly are; yet you never guided yourself its requirement. The decisions you make cannot be independent and unbiased,” she said, addressing the judge and urging him to submit his withdrawal personally not to allow others to do that instead of him.


All the legal successors and representatives joined the motion.


Valery Permyakov, who stands as the key accused in the proceeding, said he had no objections. His reply apparently left the judge astounded, as he asked the court interpreter whether he had really understood the point of the matter. 


The court adjourned for an hour to prepare a decision.

___________________________________________________________________________________


After returning to the courtroom following the break, the court announced that they were rejecting the motion.


The court said they neither violated the Civil Procedure Code nor feel any restraints.


The next hearing is scheduled for Friday, January 22.