The truth Berlin won’t tell about Turkey - WSJ
By Asli Aydintasbas
Like everyone growing up in Turkey, I was taught at school that Armenians were an ungrateful race who sided with the Russians during World War I in order to carve up the Ottoman Empire, only to be deported en mass in 1915 as an emergency measure. We learned that while some Armenians died along the way, they had massacred many Turks, that this kind of stuff happens in wartime, and that the world was conspiring to spread lies about “the so-called genocide” in order to weaken us, the Republic of Turkey.
It took me almost 20 years to undo the brainwashing of the first 20 years of my life and discover the full truth.
What really happened is that in 1915 Armenians in the eastern provinces rose up for greater rights and autonomy. They were among the oldest Christian communities in the Middle East and an integral part of the empire, with many politicians, artisans, diplomats and businessmen. The wartime Ottoman government responded with harsher and harsher measures, finally putting in effect a policy of ethnic cleansing for more than one million Armenians in 1915 across the entire region that is now called Turkey.
With systematic purges and well-orchestrated mass killings, Anatolia was “cleansed” of one of its most ancient civilizations. All traces of Armenian life and culture were erased at the foundation of the new republic in 1923. It is as if they never lived there.
Last week, 101 years after this tragedy, the German Parliament recognized the mass killings of Armenians in 1915 as “genocide,” agreeing with most scholars on the subject. The Bundestag isn’t the first parliament to condemn this first genocidal spree of the 20th century—28 parliaments around the world have passed similar laws in the past few decades. But this vote matters immensely because it highlights imperial Germany’s complicity in this tragedy.
At the time, the German government was the closest ally of the Ottomans and had military consultants embedded with the Ottoman army across the empire. Historic evidence reveals that plans to purge Armenians from mainland Anatolia were shared with German officials at various stages of the campaign.
The current co-leader of Germany’s Green party, Cem Özdemir, himself of Turkish decent, spoke passionately in support of the motion. “They knew exactly what was going on,” Mr. Özdemir said of German officers. “In this respect we’re guilty of complicity and have to admit it.”
It’s impossible not to admire the courage of Turkish-German politicians like Mr. Özdemir, who resisted pressure from Ankara and its sizable Turkish constituency inside Germany and pushed for the probe into one of the darkest periods of Turkish history. All 11 Bundestag members of Turkish background voted in favor of the resolution.
While Ankara’s official response to the German government seemed measured enough to avoid a full blow-up in relations, its anger was directed on Mr. Özdemir and other deputies who supported the vote. Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan had been issuing condolences to the Armenian victims of 1915 for the past three years. But this time he fumed that deputies who supported the vote “should have their blood samples tested in a laboratory,” suggesting there may be a hidden un-Turkishness to be revealed, very much evoking the abominable 20th-century Germanic obsession with racial purity.
What to call 1915 remains the greatest taboo in Turkey. While the government now accepts that terrible suffering was inflicted on the Armenians, it still invests millions of dollars every year in global campaigns to refute the g-word. “Bad stuff happened but it doesn’t amount to genocide” is an abridged version of
the official Turkish position.
The public is even more reactionary than the government, thanks to a policy of denial enforced for decades on every level of the school curriculum, media and academia. Even posting a simple photo of Armenian orphans from 1915 on social media instantly draws dozens of hate letters, as I experienced on numerous occasions over the past year.
In this suffocating intellectual atmosphere, one would assume that the Bundestag’s vote might be a breath of fresh air and an opening for the small but growing number of mavericks in academia and politics who now challenge Turkey’s dogma. But hardly so.
By unleashing a wave of nationalist frenzy in Turkey, the vote makes the lives of those who try to speak truth to power even more difficult. Turkey isn’t going through a “normal” period these days. Free speech is muffled. The media are stifled under an increasingly authoritarian regime. Dozens of academics who challenge the government’s harsh tactics on the Kurdish issue have been fired or detained.
And while all that was happening, German Chancellor Angela Merkel was busy shuttling back and forth to Ankara, ignoring the sharp deterioration in Turkish democracy in order to strike a refugee deal with Mr. Erdogan. At the encouragement of Germany, the European Union in March agreed to ditch its own principles and expedite Turkey’s accession process—as journalists were going on trial day after day for what they write.
EU officials uttered not a peep on press freedoms, the pressures on the judiciary or the dire human-rights situation in Kurdish areas, until the European public finally protested the double standard.
The German government is courageous to face its past, but what it should also question is its policy of omertà about the present. Turkish democrats have grown deeply suspicious of Berlin’s politicking over the past year, seeing their struggles ignored for the sake of a handshake on migrants. The vote on history won’t change that.
No country in Europe is more important for Turks than Germany—home to almost 4 million Turkish citizens and the major force behind the European Union. There is scope in that relationship for a real alliance to lift both nations and make an immense contribution to Turkish democracy. For this to happen, Berlin needs to engage with the diverse levels of Turkish society and uphold its own core principles, not just on history but on what is happening today.









